28, No CPA, 4.5 YOE. Somehow "failed upward" into an Accounting Manager role at a F200 sub. Need to relocate to NYC/LI/NJ for family but terrified I can’t hang with big city accountants.
retained text
**TL;DR:** I have 4.5 YOE, no CPA, and no target school pedigree. Survived a brutal F200 acquisition by building the accounting department from scratch, while knowing nothing myself and being given a Manager title 6 months into the job. Now making $102k in MCOL Upstate NY. I got stuck in upstate for school and work and haven’t seemed to be able to find my exit yet. I hate it here. I miss my family. I need to move to NJ/NYC/Long Island for family and need $150k+ to survive (if not 160+ due to VHCOL), but severe imposter syndrome makes me doubt that I can get a job paying me that much. What exit ops are realistic? I started my career in public at a Top 50 firm for 2.5 years in upstate NY. I jumped to industry as a Senior Accountant for a MCOL Upstate NY company that had just been acquired by an F200. At the time, the team was literally just the VP of Finance and me. The VP wanted nothing to do with the acquisition, so they bumped me to Manager of accounting and tasked me with building the team alone. Over the last two years, I hired 3 staff (who are 20+ years older than me) and pushed for a controllership hire as well. I simultaneously worked with outside consultants to properly develop a true month end close, implement all the systems, a new type of revenue recognition (POC), conversion from cash to accrual basis, and attempted to implement as many controls as I could for first-time audit readiness. Despite doing all of this, I feel like my career is going into the toilet. The last two years of implementation were misery—long hours and zero mentorship. I just had to figure it out and hope I wasn't screwing up. I don't have a CPA (and don't think I want one). I have massive gaps in my foundational knowledge because I goofed off early in college and never worked standard AP or Payroll. My staff handles that now, while I just do JEs, close the books, and handle rev rec. I pushed off forecasting to the controller because I truly was in over my head. I feel like an imposter because I can’t speak to the P&L as quickly as some of you, and I fear the next job is going to eat me alive. I subtly hide from any AP and payroll issues because I simply can’t speak to them as well as my staff (who have been doing those things for 20+ years) and I just have too much on my plate to ignore. Could I realistically land 160k+ in LI/NYC/NJ? What roles should I be targeting that offer actual career trajectory without throwing me back into 80-hour-week implementation misery? I worry my background and experience hasn’t been high tech/flashy enough. I’d rather not live in manhattan (or commute to manhattan for that matter). Ideally I’d still be able to max out my retirement as well and afford myself a 1br apartment, with some street parking as well. I’ve also rekindled a love for a couple old hobbies that are keeping me going, so if I take a job where I’m working 60+ hours each week again, I really worry I won’t last because I need time for those hobbies to keep me grounded and feel like a human being. Attached a redacted copy of resume with all the stuff I’ve been able to be involved in for reference as well. Any honest advice is welcomed. I just want to see my family again. I get 2 weeks of PTO (kill me) and can never use it. Haven’t been able to spend quality time with family for 10 years ever since getting stuck upstate due to school.
document fetched 2026-09-22 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1wmbxxn/28_no_cpa_45_yoe_somehow_failed_upward_into_an