← sources

What if India had USA tax system?

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaTax)published 2026-10-24 03:26ingested 2026-10-24 11:02

retained text

Maharashtra: The Sovereign Superpower

Under the Current System: Maharashtra is India's financial powerhouse, generating massive amounts of direct tax and GST. However, under the current Finance Commission formulas, for every ₹100 Maharashtra contributes to the central tax pool, it historically receives back only around ₹7 to ₹8. The rest is re-distributed by the Centre to poorer states.

Under the US System: Maharashtra keeps 100% of its state-generated taxes. The state bu-dget would instantly skyrocket with hundreds of thousands of crores in surplus revenue. The Chief Minister of Maharashtra could single-handedly fund hyper-loops, bullet trains, world-class ports, and massive tax breaks for tech companies without needing a single permission from New Delhi.

Bihar: The Fiscal Collapse

Under the Current System: Bihar has a low industrial base, meaning it cannot generate enough local tax to sustain itself. It relies heavily on the Central Government. For every ₹100 Bihar contributes to the central pool, it receives back well over ₹200 to ₹300. In fact, roughly 60% to 70% of Bihar's entire state bu-dget comes directly from central transfers.

Under the US System: The central pool disappears. Bihar is left entirely on its own. Its bu-dget would instantly contract by more than half. To pay the salaries of government teachers, police officers, and doctors, the Chief Minister of Bihar would be forced to levy astronomical state income and property taxes on a population that is already financially strained, leading to severe economic depression and mass migration to states like Maharashtra

I mean bihar already contributes to mass migration to MH despite the current taxation system.

document fetched 2026-10-25 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1xdy34x/what_if_india_had_usa_tax_system