← sources

Investing globally from India- cross-border friction is quietly eating our returns

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaInvestments)published 2026-10-19 14:52ingested 2026-10-20 02:40

retained text

We all love US stocks, but cross-border friction is quietly eating our returns. That's what we found in our recent findings. Below is the breakdown.

Our recent paper ran the math on what actually happens when an Indian resident invests directly in US equities. We see the 13% CAGR on our screens, but the real-world corpus tells a different story. 

Assuming you invest ₹12 lakh a year into US shares for 15 years at an expected 13% growth rate, here is the reality check:

*   **What you expect on paper:** ₹5.48 crore
*   **What you actually get:** ₹5.14 crore
*   **The total drag:** You lose roughly ₹33.87 lakh (about 6.18%) just to transfer frictions and compliance rules.

Here is exactly where that ₹34 lakh leaks out of your portfolio:

**1. US Dividend Tax (₹23.55 lakh):** 
This is by far the biggest leak. The US flat-out deducts 25% on your dividends. Because that money never gets reinvested, losing the compounding effect over 15 years costs you a massive ₹23.5 lakh in lost corpus. Yes, FTC is available, see below. 

**2. Forex Spreads (₹8.22 lakh):** 
Banks never give you the Google exchange rate. Between currency markups and transfer fees, you lose roughly 1.5% on every single deposit before the money even reaches your US broker. And when the money returns back to you in India is additional same drag.

**3. The TCS Wait (₹2.10 lakh):** 
Under LRS, sending over ₹10 lakh a year attracts 20% TCS. Yes, you get this back when you file your ITR, but your capital is locked up for about 12 months. The lost opportunity cost (the growth that money would have made) comes to ₹2.1 lakh.

**How to fix the biggest leak (FTC)**
The good news is the dividend tax hit is largely avoidable. Since India also taxes dividends at your slab rate, you can claim the Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) when filing your returns to offset the 25% the US already took. If you forget to file Form 67 and claim it, you suffer brutal double taxation (US 25% + India up to 31.2%). 

Basically, US equity returns are great, but you have to factor in the ~6% drag from forex and TCS lock-ins. And if you are investing offshore directly, claiming the FTC is an absolute non-negotiable.

document fetched 2026-10-20 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaInvestments/comments/1x9yzsd/investing_globally_from_india_crossborder