FAST-DS Gaps/Clarifications/Questions
retained text
I am just opening this thread to collate more queries on the FAST-DS scheme to share with the a few senior officers in CBDT. **My list looks like this. Feel free to add more items.** 1. **Valuation of foreign bank accounts for periods of non-resident or RNOR status - Make it consistent with VDS scheme disclosures.** **2. Whether undisclosed foreign income is computed under the Income-tax Act or the Black Money Act** Clarification is requested on: (a) which statute governs the computation of undisclosed foreign income declared under Table Sl. No. 1; (b) whether losses on sale of foreign shares may be set off against gains in the same year; (c) whether credit is available for foreign tax already withheld on such income, typically US withholding on dividends; and (d) which exchange rate should apply to income of earlier years. **3. Assets below ₹20 lakh where there is no undisclosed income** Clarification is requested on: (a) whether a declaration under the Scheme is necessary for such taxpayers; (b) whether the ₹20 lakh relief extends to defaults of previous years before 1 October 2024 in which no penalty has yet been imposed; and (c) which value is to be used in applying the ₹20 lakh threshold. **Suggestion.** Allow such taxpayers to file a declaration under Table Sl. No. 2 without payment of any fee, where: (a) the aggregate value of their foreign assets (other than immovable property) does not exceed ₹20 lakh; and (b) there is no undisclosed foreign income. **4. Partial declarations** 4.1 Section 132 permits a declaration in respect of any income or asset falling within section 133. Immunity under section 139 extends only to the income or asset so declared (FAQ 48). The limits in section 133 are tested on aggregate value (Rule 4, Illustration 3), and section 134(3) makes a declaration void if particulars are false. 4.2 It is not clear whether: (a) a declarant may use the Scheme for some items and regularise others through an updated return under section 139(8A), for example declaring RSU shares under Table Sl. No. 2 while offering the related dividend income in ITR-U; and (b) the ₹1 crore and ₹5 crore limits are tested on the items declared or on all foreign assets held by the declarant. Guidance on both points would help declarants avoid inadvertent invalidity under section 134(3). ***(In a session in Hyderabad yesterday, IT Officers clearly stated that they wont recognise ITRU disclosures)*** **5. Form 1 does not capture sold assets or reinvestment** 5.1 Rule 3 provides that an asset sold before the valuation date is valued at the higher of cost and sale consideration. It also provides that where sale proceeds or withdrawals are reinvested in another asset, the value of the original asset is reduced by the amount reinvested (FAQ 34). 5.2 Form 1, including Schedule A5(a) for quoted shares, has no field to show: * that a lot was sold, with its sale date and consideration; or * that it was acquired by reinvesting proceeds or income declared elsewhere in the form. A value correctly computed under Rule 3 may therefore appear inconsistent with the 31 March 2026 market price. That exposes the declarant to the risk of being treated as having furnished incorrect particulars, and the 20% tolerance in Rule 5(2) does not address this. 5.3 Suggestion: Form 1 provide for: (a) the status of each item as held or sold on the valuation date; (b) the date and consideration of sale; (c) the source of funds (taxed income, income earned while non-resident, or undisclosed income);. and (d) a reference to the item from which the asset was funded, where the reinvestment provision is applied. **Also, as has been done by a few people in this community, feel free to bombard CBDT with your queries. More the merrier.**
document fetched 2026-11-14 00:51 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1xuyxwq/fastds_gapsclarificationsquestions