I’ve been on Etsy for 7 months and I genuinely can’t figure out what’s stopping my shop from converting — would love a brutally honest audit
retained text
Hi everyone! I’m looking for some honest feedback on my Etsy shop because I genuinely can’t figure out what’s going wrong. My shop sells Y2K / McBling / feminine slogan graphic tees, aimed mainly at women who like baddie, brat, early-2000s and “main character” fashion. I currently have around 45 listings and I’m getting traffic, favorites and some engagement, but sales are still much lower than I expected. i got 2 orders in June and 2 in july , and after that no orders till now I’ve already experimented with things like: Etsy SEO/titles/tags Pinterest marketing Different mockups Discounts/coupons Pricing Listing photos Branding But I’m clearly missing something. What I’d really like you to tell me is: Does the shop look professional/trustworthy at first glance? Do the products actually look desirable, or do they look like generic POD? Do the mockups make you want to click/buy? Does the pricing feel justified for these products? Is my niche/brand positioning clear? Is the size and fit description clear or not? Do you see anything that would make you hesitate before buying? If you were running this shop, what 3 things would you change first? Most importantly: where do you think the biggest conversion problem is? Please be honest - If something looks cheap, generic, overpriced, confusing, or simply not marketable, pls let me know Shop: [https://papmeoutsidee.etsy.com](https://papmeoutsidee.etsy.com) Current stats:( 7 months ) • Listings: 45 • Visits : 1,195 • Orders: 3 ( ONLY 2 PEOPLE HAVE ORDERED YET , AND 1 OF THEM IS A REPEAT BUYER SHE BOUGHT 3 TEES AND ALSO LEFT REVIEWS FOR EACH ONE) • Conversion rate: 0.3% • Favorites: 301 • Reviews: 3 •Abandoned carts: 34 I’m especially interested in hearing from people who sell on Etsy themselves, particularly in apparel/fashion/POD. Thanks in advance — I’m trying to figure out what I’m not seeing from my side.
document fetched 2026-09-26 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wpvcaq/ive_been_on_etsy_for_7_months_and_i_genuinely