Why Is the Government Selling a Bank That Made ₹9,513 Crore in Profit? IDBI Bank: From ₹35,000 Crore Losses to a ₹52,878 Crore Sale – The Complete Story
retained text
I recently read about the IDBI Bank stake sale and decided to dig a little deeper into its history, financial performance, ownership changes and the reasons behind the proposed sale. This post is based on my own reading, research and understanding of publicly available information. I'm still new to this kind of research and learning along the way, so this is an educational attempt from my perspective, not an attempt to start a political debate or promote any particular political viewpoint. **Let's keep the discussion informative, respectful and open-minded**❤️ **1. The birth of IDBI in 1964** The Government of India established the Industrial Development Bank of India (IDBI) under the Industrial Development Bank of India Act, 1964. It officially came into existence on **1 July 1964.** But there is an interesting detail here. IDBI was initially established as a wholly owned subsidiary of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). But in 1976, its ownership was transferred from RBI to the Government of India. So yes IDBI's creation in 1964 and the transfer of its ownership in 1976 both happened during Congress-led governments. The old IDBI was not merely lending money to companies it was helping create the financial infrastructure that India needed to grow. In 1991, India introduced major economic reforms the economy gradually moved towards greater competition private-sector participation and the banking sector also started changing. **2. What lead to Conversion from DFI into commercial bank ?** In April 2000, the RBI announced that DFIs could opt to convert into commercial banks provided they fulfilled the applicable prudential requirements IDBI was not simply changing its business model because the financial system was evolving. It was also dealing with a significant level of bad loans. On 1 October 2004 IDBI officially became a banking company. **3. Why did LIC has to Step in ?** When IDBI became a commercial bank in 2004 it inherited a large portfolio of loans from its earlier development-finance business. Some of these loans were not being repaid properly. On 5 May 2017, the Reserve Bank of India placed IDBI Bank under the Prompt Corrective Action (PCA) framework. What **does PCA mean?** Think of it as a warning system when a bank financial health becomes weak the RBI can impose restrictions to prevent the situation from becoming worse. On **1 August 2018, t**he Union Cabinet approved the proposal allowing LIC to acquire a controlling stake in IDBI Bank LIC completed the acquisition of a 51% controlling stake on **21 January 2019**. **4. Govt intervention** In September 2019, the Union Cabinet approved a government capital infusion of ₹4,557 crore into IDBI Bank LIC was expected to contribute ₹4,743 crore together the two shareholders were to provide ₹9,300 crore to support the bank's financial recovery. The government said IDBI needed this one-time support to deal with its legacy loan book and return to normal lending. **5. Lifting of PCA Restriction** On 10 March 2021, the RBI lifted the PCA restrictions imposed on IDBI Bank this was an important milestone. **6. Now move to Important Discussion** In FY 25-26 IDBI Net profit was 9513 Croce the latest figures are encouraging its bad loan have also declined and capital is strong so many are questioning why govt is selling despite profitability ? The proposed deal is to sell LIC holding of 30.48% and Govt holding 30.24%. After the deal govt will still hold 15 % and LIC 19%. The government says it wants to reduce its involvement It expects the new strategic investor to bring Private capital , New technology etc. **The ₹52,878 crore question How was IDBI Bank valued?** The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs approved Fairfax's wholly owned subsidiary, 10955230 Canada Inc., as the strategic buyer on 14 October 2026. The winning bid is Rs 52,878.08 Croce for a 60.72% stake in IDBI bank at a price of Rs 81 per share where book value was Rs 75.99. The initial reserve price was 94.42 the round does not succeed. But a question comes to mind that what does the deal not happened at mkt price that is listed on exchange so Govt explained that IDBI stock is Volatile and it fluctuated between 60 to 120 approx. so they relied on Valuation method first one they compared it with other Peer Companies and Other is Asset Valuation method in which you take out fair value of asset minus fair value of liability. Two independent professional valuation agencies were appointed. The average of the two independent valuations was ₹75.99 per share. This became the benchmark price for evaluating the bids. Fairfax submitted a winning offer of ₹81 per share. The detailed valuation reports are not publicly disclosed **7. A little brief about Fairfax and Why Employees have raised a parliamentary assurance** Prem Watsa, Founder, Chairman and CEO of Fairfax Financial Holdings. He founded Fairfax in 1985 and has led the company since then. Prem Watsa is an Indian-born Canadian businessman and investor. He is often compared with Warren Buffett because of his long-term investment philosophy and his background in insurance and value investing. Fairfax operates through subsidiaries in different countries. One of the most important arguments in the opposition to the sale. The employees forum has referred to an assurance made by then Finance Minister Jaswant Singh during the parliamentary discussion around IDBI's conversion into a bank. According to the forum the assurance was that the government would maintain at least 51% shareholding. The forum argues that the proposed sale goes against that assurance. #
document fetched 2026-11-02 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1xl3emk/why_is_the_government_selling_a_bank_that_made