Are we measuring software engineers by the wrong things?
retained text
I've been thinking about how software engineering is evaluated, especially in the Indian tech industry. For years, the hiring process has placed significant emphasis on DSA, competitive programming, framework knowledge, and the ability to solve problems under interview conditions. These skills have their place. But I'm wondering whether they tell us enough about someone's ability to work as a software engineer. In real projects, engineering involves much more: * Understanding an unfamiliar codebase. * Debugging issues that cannot be reproduced consistently. * Making architectural decisions with long-term consequences. * Identifying security and performance trade-offs. * Reviewing code written by other developers. * Taking responsibility for systems running in production. AI tools are making code generation faster, but they don't automatically eliminate the need for engineering judgment. **My question is:** Should the Indian software industry rethink how it evaluates developers? Would practical engineering assessments, debugging exercises, system design, and code-review tasks be better indicators than traditional interview rounds alone? I'd particularly like to hear from experienced engineers, technical interviewers, and people involved in hiring.
document fetched 2026-11-19 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/developersIndia/comments/1xz7377/are_we_measuring_software_engineers_by_the_wrong