AI usage in creative media(in the non-creative parts)
retained text
So recently with the huge rise of AI generated games coming out as models get better and better, there's a lot many people who absolutely hate AI and its usage in creative media. And they're absolutely right to do so, especially if it's illegally trained off of other artists works. but I've got some questions that don't make sense to me because they kind of feel like the same thing, whether one uses ai or not as it's just making the process less tedious(Not meaning to say that the process isn't part of the fun/journey, just for tedious stuff). Say that I'm a game dev who's just starting out and I want to build games. Instead of watching hour long tutorials/browsing articles or going on stack overflow waiting for answers that don't make sense, i instead decide to use AI to teach myself. Now what would this be about, you ask? well, as we've seen, AI is pretty terrible at anything that requires creativity or thinking out of the box. That means anything related to art, design, animation,etc. is out of the question. However, the things I want to focus on are the technical aspects. Things like performance optimisation, learning how to code graphics/textures(I believe there's a lot of maths involved, but maybe I'm wrong),etc. So if I were making a game, and instead of painstakingly searching through Google about optimisation techniques and stuff, and then putting it into my game only to lose so many times, frustrate myself and throw it out the window, vs using ai to teach me those techniques very simply and easily, isn't it the same thing? Is learning from AI and then using it in your creations considered AI usage? As a student, i feel like AI is very useful in teaching, so much better than my current professors. And to take it a step further, what if, I were to use AI to code these technical aspects of a game? it would be similar to going around google searching for optimisation then copying it and changing it to fit my game, the same work and result that could be easily done from using AI. What if I was an artist and I loved the idea of making my own game, I loved art, design and animations, but maybe I wasn't good at technical performance? Maybe I didn't know how to optimise my game for devices, how to port it to other OS, how to make graphics/textures work? If I used AI to teach myself optimised code and wrote it vs using AI to directly make code that brings those optimisations/performance, isn't it the same thing with less steps? Taking it the other way around, if I was a person who's good at coding but not art, then it would be unacceptable to use AI. I guess that is a good counter to my question, as many will argue that coding is in equal parts an art as is traditional art in game design. Ofcourse, for someone who loves coding as a hobby, and sitting through racking their brain on finding ingenious solutions (or really stupid stuff that somehow works and they have no clue why) on the technical aspects of their work, it'll be absolutely blasphemous, and they're in the right to go against AI. Technically in the past before AI, game dev was equal parts art+ code, atleast how I see it. With the introduction of AI, I think it's now turned into more art than code, as AI can help give us a basic understanding of what to do and how to do it. Giving it free reign is definitely a bad idea though. This is a dilemma that I've always had on my mind ever since the ai generated slop games started appearing. One one hand, you've got more slop being generated in a day than the amount of hairs on your body. On the other hand, there might genuinely be people with a great vision, someone with an original idea and a good sense of design make a game their own way. They could try hiring a developer out of their own money, they could try going out to Collab with other single Dev's for an indie game, though that may have a lot of complications as people will have different ideas and interests. So if AI does allow one to make a game, a game which is already great when it comes to the traditional and original aspects- design, art direction, characters, writing, gameplay features(concept versions, not coded) , models,etc. And I use AI in the other aspects that many companies(and indie devs, inevitably due to lack of time, interest or experience) gloss over, like performance optimisation, fixing graphical glitches/refining textures, porting to other OS. (Edit: )For a person who isn't technically sound, maybe they couldnt spend enough time wanting to learn those aspects? Maybe they tried but found it very boring? Maybe they tried to force themselves to sit through it only to realise they'll never have interest in that specific technical part? Maybe I'm going off a lose screw, but this sort of thing has always confused me. Edit: The point of this post isn't to mock people who hate ai or defend the usage of ai in a game or stand on a moral high ground if I would bad for using AI I just want to understand the reasoning behind all games with AI used in them are slop, and to what extent? I didn't mean to offend anybody or anything like that. My wording night also be bad because english isn't my native language.
document fetched 2026-10-31 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xj12xk/ai_usage_in_creative_mediain_the_noncreative_parts