← sources

Adobe and Salesforce both spent $30B+ on buybacks in 5 years. Adobe has 12.1% fewer shares. Salesforce has more.

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-11-15 15:37ingested 2026-11-16 02:39

retained text

Just comparing the businesses here, not the stocks. I went through the last five 10-Ks (Adobe FY2021-FY2025, Salesforce FY2022-FY2026) to see how much of the cash actually reached shareholders.



Buybacks over five years: Adobe $35.7B, Salesforce $32.0B. Diluted shares: Adobe 485.5M to 427.0M (12.1% fewer). Salesforce 930M to 956M (2.8% more).



What explains the gap (cash flow statement, five-year totals, my calculation):

• Net buybacks (repurchases minus proceeds from employee stock plans): Adobe $34.1B, Salesforce $25.4B.

• Stock pay (SBC): Adobe $8.0B, Salesforce $15.5B. As a share of sales they are close: 8.2% vs 9.0%. As a share of net buybacks: 23.5% vs 61.3%.

• Salesforce also issued $11.1B of stock for Slack in 2021. Stock pay plus Slack stock = $26.6B, more than its net buybacks.



Per $100 of free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capex):

• Returned to owners (dividends + net buybacks): Adobe $88, Salesforce $59 ($7 dividends, $53 net buybacks; from unrounded figures).

• Add acquisitions paid in cash: Adobe $95, Salesforce $117 (from unrounded figures). In FY2026 Salesforce spent $8.0B more than its FCF and raised $6.0B of new debt; its notes list $6.0B under two Informatica credit agreements.



Where this could be wrong:

• Stock pay is valued at grant, buybacks at the price paid. Comparing dollars is rough; share counts are the cleaner test.

• Weighted-average diluted shares lag. Slack shows up fully only in FY2023.

• Fiscal years end two months apart.

• Free cash flow here doesn't subtract stock pay. Subtract it and FCF is 21% lower at Adobe and 32% lower at Salesforce.



My read: at Salesforce, most of the buybacks went to replacing the shares it issued, to employees and for Slack. So cash went back to shareholders, but the slice didn't grow. The 10-K can't tell us yet if the acquisitions will earn more than they cost.



For people who track SBC closely: do you count buybacks that offset dilution as "returned to shareholders", or as a compensation cost?

I wrote this up with the tables and sources here (my own newsletter): [https://inwoinvesting.substack.com/p/adobe-vs-salesforce-30-billion-of](https://inwoinvesting.substack.com/p/adobe-vs-salesforce-30-billion-of)

document fetched 2026-11-16 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xwyhrv/adobe_and_salesforce_both_spent_30b_on_buybacks