← sources

Forced RTO - Recommendations on how to negotiate layoff meeting?

source: reddit (reddit:layoffs)published 2026-11-03 03:53ingested 2026-11-04 02:41

retained text

Hello lovely people of Reddit,

I am reaching out to this community because I’m facing an unexpected situation at work while dealing with a recent family loss, and I could really use some grounded advice and guidance on how to negotiate my exit.



I live in SW Washington and work remotely 40 hours/week as a Licensed Healthcare Case Manager for a CCO organization based in Oregon.



At the start of the year, our team had 10 people on the medical side. Work piled up heavily (caseloads reaching \~200 per coordinator when safe guidelines are 50). Over time, people left, leaving only 3 of us.



I am currently out of the office on approved bereavement leave (using my accrued PTO, pre-approved by management) and scheduled to return on Monday, 11/9.



While out on leave, a coworker tipped me off to check my work email; HR sent a notice stating that the department is transitioning to a mandatory hybrid arrangement (3 days/week in-office at headquarters) effective 11/10. The email acknowledged that this change may not be feasible for employees living at a distance and offered a severance package for those who cannot make the transition, setting a decision deadline of 11/2.



I also received the same work email today 11/2 on **my personal email,** however the email stated that we had a weekend to think this over and then get back to them by 11/2 (the same day I got the email), which makes me assume that the email was supposed to be sent out on 10/30 to the work email instead. HQ is an estimated \~300-mile round trip from my home (6 hours of driving per day). Daily or 3x/week commuting is physically and geographically impossible.



I am still on approved bereavement until 11/9, but HR scheduled a Zoom meeting with me for my return date to discuss the transition/severance.



I recently bought a house and have a mortgage to support, so this sudden shift during an already painful personal loss feels crushing. I want to make sure I advocate for myself properly and don't leave money on the table.



HR’s initial baseline offer is around 4.5 weeks of base pay ($7,500). My goal is to submit a formal **counter-proposal** for 8 to 12 weeks of base pay + 2 months of COBRA health coverage support. 



These are the reasons as to why I want to propose a counter offer:

\-Impossible RTO: I was hired and worked as a 100% remote out-of-state employee. Doing a 300-mile daily commute is impossible, therefore this sounds like a position elimination  / constructive dismissal rather than a standard voluntary resignation.

**-**Heavy Workload: During the downsizing, HR did not hire people, which caused the medical team of 3 people to carry the department through a massive downsizing from 10 coordinators to 3. This was 4x the safe clinical threshold to maintain patient care continuity. 

\-Bereavement Disruption: I received the email that issued the sudden decision window while I am on pre-approved bereavement to my personal email with incorrect dates. They informed me that I had the weekend to think about the choice and to reply to the email EOD 11/2/26 - I was sent the email at 11 am on 11/26 while still being on my approved bereavement. 

\-Need For Health Benefit Continuity: Out-of-pocket COBRA premiums run $600–$800 per month. Bridging healthcare coverage until securing a new clinical role is a real financial necessity due to health care issues I have. 



I have never been in a situation like this, which is why I am asking for further guidance. 



Some of the questions I would greatly appreciate help with

1. Severance Counter-Offer Strategy - For those in HR or healthcare management, what is the best way to structure and deliver a written counter-proposal for 8–12 weeks and COBRA without risking the baseline offer?
2. Bereavement & Meeting Boundaries - What key questions or boundary-setting statements should I use during my Zoom call on 11/9 to ensure I take the agreement home to review without signing under pressure?



**\*Note for the upcoming comments:** *I understand that Oregon law does not mandate severance by default and that employers are not legally required to offer standard packages. I am specifically seeking advice from people with experience negotiating severance counter-proposals or handling remote position eliminations on how to frame these points effectively in writing.*



Thank you all so much for your empathy, wisdom, and support during a really difficult time <3 

document fetched 2026-11-04 00:42 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Layoffs/comments/1xmisk5/forced_rto_recommendations_on_how_to_negotiate