If you’re ok with your game being pirated then it makes no sense to worry about AI reverse engineering or decompilation
retained text
A lot of the discourse here and in other subs around the recent wave of AI reverse engineered software is driving me crazy, so I figured I’d come on here and share some information to clear up a lot of misconceptions. Let’s start with some definitions: # Reverse Engineering Reverse Engineering (in software) is the practice of creating a piece of software with the same feature set as some existing software. Traditionally this is done with a “black box” approach, where, in order to keep things legally compliant, 2 teams are deployed. One team creates a spec, a document with as many details as possible about how the software works and what its features are, and the other team writes software from scratch based on those requirements. Critically, Team B never sees the original source code, and thus the company does not commit intellectual property theft. For example, we’ve all played Mario right? Nintendo can’t sue you for IP theft if your game has a jump mechanic because you didn’t take Mario’s source code. Legal precedent is that game mechanics are not your intellectual property. This is a good thing because it means we can mix and match mechanics from different games creatively to make new cool stuff. # Decompilation Decompiling is completely different, it’s taking a binary and converting it to human readable code. This can be easy or hard depending on the programming language the binary was compiled from. For example C# is easy to decompile with full method names, in other languages you may just have generic method and variable names. Decompiling on its own isn’t necessarily illegal, but you cannot use decompiled code in your own projects because that *is* intellectual property. # What Does This Have To Do With Piracy? First let’s clear something up: if parts of a game are Reverse Engineered, this is not piracy. We should all be happy this is how the law works because it means we can all use mechanics from each others games and make creative contributions to the space by combining different mechanics. Pirating a game *usually* requires decompiling the binary so that you can modify it, to avoid DRM for example. This literally is IP theft. Based on [this post I made a few months ago](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/s/698VSe8gkV) I know that most devs on this sub are fine with their games being pirated. And that’s fine, but now I’m seeing a fair few people up in arms about AI being used to reverse engineer or decompile their games… So I’m just wondering, what’s up guys? I thought we were fine with our games being fully pirated, why are we all of a sudden hawks for IP theft? Is it possible that this fear is just a knee-jerk reaction to the latest AI news? Just curious!
document fetched 2026-10-12 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1x2v1ty/if_youre_ok_with_your_game_being_pirated_then_it