← sources

A question about a factorial operator

source: lobsterspublished 2026-07-31 05:05ingested 2026-08-01 08:08

retained text

<p>I wrote an assembler that supports floating point values.  One of the operators I implemented was factorial because a lot of Taylor series seem to use it to define various constants.  So right now, I have</p>
<pre><code>.float	-((2*3.14159265)**11)/11!
</code></pre>
<p>I found a bug in the parsing such that <code>(2+3)!</code> doesn't parse (the parsing of the factorial operator is in the wrong location).  In fixing the bug, I found an issue that I don't know how best to resolve, since I personally have never used a programming language that defined a factorial operator.  So my question:  what should <code>-3!</code> produce?  Should it error out as factorial isn't defined for negative numbers?  Or should it parse as <code>-(3!)</code> and return -6?  I ask because of <code>-(2+3)!</code>.  What binds tighter?  The minus, or the factorial?</p>
Tags: ask, compilers

document fetched 2026-08-01 08:08