I've never been hired after a "roleplay"
retained text
Hi guys, Over the past two years I've been a bit unfortunate with my job search and have found myself endlessly grinding the job search.....twice in two years. That means, I've gone through close to 50 job application processes, each with several interview rounds and often concluding in some sort of "roleplay" or presentation. The thing is, I have NEVER received a job offer after such roleplays. Not once. I do well in general presentations, I know my circle of competence. I pass the IQ tests etc. But I just can't seem to get positive feedback from roleplay scenarios. And my gut feeling is, it's not really me. My feeling is that "roleplay" settings or excercises are just contrived to give recruiters and hiring managers a blank slate on which to reject the candidate for any reason they feel like. After all, interpreting the results is completely subjective. Equally, the feedback and reason given (if any) are always all over the place with no consistent through lines. So there's never any valuable lesson to be learnt or specifics I can improve for the next call. The only job offers I ever got were when the application process was simple and mostly based on vibes and knowledge checks. Edit: maybe this wasn't clear but I have ~10 years experience as an Account Executive, incl. closing 7-digit Enterprise deals and committed contracts. Most people interviewing me have consultancy backgrounds.
document fetched 2026-09-08 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sales/comments/1w9z9kv/ive_never_been_hired_after_a_roleplay