← sources

Why are people against caste-based reservation?

source: reddit (reddit:india)published 2026-10-06 17:10ingested 2026-10-07 02:38

retained text

​

I support caste-based reservation because it gives people from historically disadvantaged communities a fair chance in education and jobs.

People often say, “SC/ST people are taking our jobs.” But SC reservation is 15% and ST reservation is 7.5% in central institutions. So how exactly are they “stealing” your jobs?

If an ST student gets selected at 60 marks while the general cutoff is 80, shouldn't we also ask why the gap exists in the first place? It shows that many people from these communities still face major disadvantages in education and opportunity.

Now imagine a future where SC/ST communities become highly educated and start competing with or even outperforming the general category. If they then take a large share of open seats, would the same people still say, “Abolish reservation”? Or would they start asking for reservation for their own community?

I'm not saying the current system is perfect. We can debate how reservation should work and whether it needs changes.

But saying “they are taking our jobs” ignores the bigger issue: why does this inequality still exist?

What do you think? 💭

document fetched 2026-10-07 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1wz85tf/why_are_people_against_castebased_reservation