← sources

MAcc and CPA Candidate getting rejected from entry-level assurance roles—what should I change?

source: reddit (reddit:Accounting)published 2026-09-20 00:47ingested 2026-09-21 02:35

retained text

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for honest advice about breaking into public accounting in Ontario.

I recently completed a CPA-accredited Master of Accountancy program at Brock University with an A average. I also have a BAcc and am a CPA Candidate. I have been applying for new-graduate and entry-level accounting, assurance and audit positions at large, mid-sized and regional firms.

My relevant experience includes:

* General ledger maintenance, journal entries, reconciliations, trial-balance analysis, supporting schedules and year-end support for a small business
* Reconciliation of more than $250,000 in monthly insurance billings at a dental office
* Designing controls over cash receipts, insurance payments and inventory after noticing recurring staff errors
* Night-audit experience involving daily revenue of more than $25,000
* Approximately 50 T1 returns, a few T2 returns and HST filings
* CaseWare, ProFile, QuickBooks, Sage 50 and Excel
* Graduate assurance training in risk assessment, materiality, internal controls, audit evidence, substantive procedures and working papers

The major weakness is that I do not have previous public-accounting or co-op experience. My audit and assurance experience is academic rather than experience conducting actual client engagements.

I have used referrals where possible and tailored my applications. One referral led to an introductory HR call with a regional firm, but there were no current openings. I was recently rejected by Doane Grant Thornton, and most of my other applications have either been rejected or received no response. I am willing to relocate anywhere in Ontario for the right opportunity.

I would genuinely appreciate blunt feedback:

1. Is my lack of public-accounting or co-op experience likely the main reason I am being rejected?
2. Should I continue targeting new-graduate assurance positions, or first pursue bookkeeping, tax technician or junior industry-accounting roles?
3. Would a one-page résumé be better, or is two pages reasonable given my education, work experience and assurance training?
4. Should I reduce the academic assurance content and focus more heavily on my practical accounting and control experience?
5. What is the best way to get that first public-accounting opportunity when most firms appear to prefer candidates who already have firm experience?

I’m not expecting anyone to sugar-coat it. I would rather understand what is weakening my applications and work on it. I can also share a fully redacted version of my résumé if anyone is willing to review it.

**TL;DR:** I’m an Ontario MAcc graduate and CPA Candidate with accounting, tax, reconciliation and internal-control experience, but no public-accounting or co-op background. I’m being rejected or ghosted for entry-level assurance roles despite using referrals and being willing to relocate. Looking for honest advice on my résumé, the roles I should target and how to get my first public-accounting opportunity.

document fetched 2026-09-21 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1wl2n45/macc_and_cpa_candidate_getting_rejected_from