← sources

Unpopular opinion: AI isn't stealing most jobs, the job market just sucks right now

source: reddit (reddit:cscareerquestions)published 2026-10-21 04:24ingested 2026-10-22 02:37

retained text

Senior SWE here, I lead a team of about 10 people.

One of the most common things I am hearing about here, on LinkedIn, in private circles, etc., is this doomer mentality that AI is going to be replacing most people in the tech world. AI replacement is happening, but it isn't as widespread as people may think. There are several loud facts about AI:

1. Most AI companies have been operating with straight losses.

2. Multiple studies have shown AI doesn't increase productivity of employees for a cost offset.

3. Many companies are giving up on AI ventures or dramatically scaling back implementations (70%-95% of AI integration efforts are failing).

4. Litigation risks from AI are growing and further making it a liability to use.

5. Public sentiment in most places is heavily leaning anti-AI.

6. Existing and planned infrastructure isn't good enough to support replacing people with AI on any massive scale.

7. All major efforts to replace large portions of staff with AI have been short term catastrophes (forget long term, we haven't gotten there yet).

Companies are firing and laying off people using AI as a reason, when really they are performing routine cuts or RoF due to overhiring (there is still a heavily saturated CS market currently from the CovID era). There are also a massive amount of software engineers looking for work. This is a supply v.s. demand issue.

It is also not helpful that we are currently in a market where people are firing off AI slop resumes to every job posting they find, causing there to be hundreds if not thousands of applicants for a job that used to see tens of applicants. Prospective new hires are also decreasing in quality due to a lot of people attempting to just sail through using AI without actually knowing engineering principles. It's a rough world right now at the entry level.

Imo, AI is impacting us, but it isn't for the reasons a lot of entry level engineers are thinking. It also definitely isn't replacing anyone well enough to be considered even remotely successful (look what happened to Klarna)... so if you do get fired or laid off actually because of AI, you can expect a panicked letter or email in the near future requesting you come back (especially if you are experienced).

document fetched 2026-10-22 00:24 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/1xbdja7/unpopular_opinion_ai_isnt_stealing_most_jobs_the