SEBI just published another study on why individual F&O traders lose money. The interesting part is that it goes beyond the usual “90% traders lose” headline.
retained text
SEBI’s FY25–FY26 study looked at trading behaviour, capital, turnover, trading frequency and experience. The findings are quite revealing. **1) Options buying dominates retail trading.** In FY26, around 97% of individual traders predominantly bought options. About 90% of only-options buyers lost money. **2) Options selling has a different risk profile.** The loss rate among majorly-options sellers was lower at 43.8%. But when they lost, the average loss was around 11 times higher than that of majorly-options buyers. **3) Trading intensity matters.** Traders active for more than 100 days represented 42% of traders, but accounted for 94% of turnover and 87% of total losses. **4) Experience did not necessarily improve outcomes.** The loss-maker rate increased from about 91% among first-year traders to more than 95% among traders with four or more consecutive years of participation. **5) Consistent profitability was extremely rare.** Among traders active throughout FY22–FY26, only 0.5% were profitable in all five years, while 65.6% lost money in every year. **6) Losses often continued when traders continued trading.** Among traders who had lost money in each of the previous two years but continued trading, 90–92% lost again in the following year. So what should an individual trader take away from this? It may not be enough to ask: **“Is my strategy profitable?”** You should also ask: **How much am I trading relative to my capital? How frequently am I trading? How large is my average loss when I am wrong? Am I continuing to trade after repeated losses simply to recover what I have already lost?** SEBI’s study does not establish that high trading intensity *causes* losses. It identifies a strong association between these behaviours and poorer outcomes. But one message is difficult to ignore: **More trading does not necessarily mean better trading.** So, is there a way to improve your chances of avoiding the same mistakes? One approach is to **backtest a trading strategy over a long period of historical data before putting real money behind it**. Backtesting cannot guarantee future returns, but it can help you understand how a strategy would have behaved across different market conditions and whether its rules have historically produced a meaningful edge. \---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- At **SanjeevResearch** portal, we have backtested our strategy across **more than a decade of historical market data**. The learnings from that testing have been incorporated into our trading process. The objective is simple: replace assumptions with evidence, and replace impulsive trading with a process that has been tested over different market conditions.
document fetched 2026-09-22 00:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1wmal6p/sebi_just_published_another_study_on_why