Manual outreach was quietly capping how many clients we took
retained text
So, last year our agency hit a point where client demand was growing faster than our ability to deliver and when we looked at where the time was going, we found out almost all of it traced back to one task and that was creator outreach, which we were still doing by hand for every brand. The math is sobering once you write it down, because a genuinely personalized DM takes about three to four minutes when you include checking the creator’s recent videos and mentioning something specific, so a single client needing 2,000 messages a month already consumes well over 100 hours, and across five clients that adds up to more than three full time people spending every working hour on messages. Well the obvious shortcut is sending generic messages in bulk, yet creators who sell well receive dozens of invites a week and recognize copy and paste outreach immediately, so reply rates collapse, and we found ourselves stuck between personalized outreach that capped our volume and mass outreach that wasted it. The way out was separating the research from the writing, since most of what makes a message personal comes from data that already exists, such as a creator’s category, their recent best selling video, the brands they have sold for and their typical content style, so we set up a flow that pulls those details for every creator on the list and builds them into message templates, which means each DM references something real about the creator while taking seconds rather than minutes to produce. From there the outreach runs as a sequence, with invites and DMs going out in batches, follow ups triggered automatically for anyone yet to reply, and the next step adjusting to what each creator does, while our top tier prospects and any creator who replies with a real question move straight to a person on the team, so the human time goes into conversations rather than first messages. Within two months each account manager was handling outreach for three or four clients instead of one, reply rates held steady at the level of our hand written messages, and the conversation with new clients shifted from how many creators we could contact to how quickly we could start, which made a real difference when pitching larger brands. Well I would be really curious to hear how other agencies handle outreach volume across multiple clients, and whether you have found a way to keep messages personal once you are sending thousands a month.....
document fetched 2026-11-03 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1xltnmn/manual_outreach_was_quietly_capping_how_many