Is It Safe to Say the Economy of the 90s Was Better for the Middle Class While The Economy of Today Benefits the Wealthy More?
retained text
So starting sometime around the Great Recession, online there became a huge mantra that the economy of the 90s was better than today and people were longing for it. I heard this on social media, forums, in survey Micro and Macro econ courses (I was not an economics major, InfoTech) and many other places throughout the 2010s. Recently, especially since about late 2024 but heavily 2025 I'm seeing in a lot of rebuttable to this, that the economy of today is better than the 90s. People often cite various links, mainly St. Louis Fed that people have more disposable income today than they did in the 90s and people's household incomes are higher than ever. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DSPIC96 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/mehoinusa672n I'm wondering if it's more complex than just that. I'm wondering if the Real Disposable Income gets skewed by the top 1% and even top 10% being wealthier than they were in the 90s and I wonder if the real median household income is due to inflation and more money. Other arguments people use is that the GDP has grown a lot since the 90s and that stocks are higher. Again, I'm wondering if these things only benefit the rich and middle class Americans don't really notice. The last major argument is that the average unemployment rate of the 2020s was lower than the unemployment rate of the 90s. This is a strong argument but I'm wondering if it's largely due to both the further death of manufacturing in rust belt cities in the 90s and the rise of the "Gig economy" keeping unemployment numbers down. Other argument that isn't as common but I have heard, is that people cite that a lot of mid-size cities in the US were awful in the 90s. Many people had already fled to bedroom communities and commuter towns. But starting in the late 2000s, main streets in these cities began to get revived and they have made a strong comeback in the 2010s with tons of coffee shops, record stores, work spaces, etc. Usually the argument for the economy of the 90s being better is that more middle class Americans were able to buy new homes for the first time, have new homes built (often 1600 sq ft or so one story homes). More middle class Americans were able to buy new cars (again nothing fancy but cars such as the Honda Accord, Toyota Corolla, Jeep Cherokee, Chevy Trailblazer, etc sold well). Despite some nostalgia most middle class Americans did not drive Toyota Supras or Pontiac Trans Ams (the sales numbers for both prove it) but many did drive cheap and reliable fwd sedans. People took more short vacations, went out more during the week, eat out at casual restaurants more. Middle class office jobs had less competitive interview process. Money seemed to go further for middle class Americans. There was a huge growth in tech, cable tv, the kids economy (the rise of cartoon network, nickelodeon and kids oriented travel), the collecting economy (baseball cards, comic books, diecast cars, beanie babies and later pokemon), indie films got slightly bigger budgets and more mainstream, both TV and film studios took more risks and approved more artistic projects (it's why we got shows like The X-Files and Sea Quest on broadcast TV). Now was everyone doing great? No. Where there homeless people and mass layoffs and people that struggled to make ends meet? Of course! Was the 90s perfect? No. Was everything back then better than today? No. Did it seem like middle class Americans were doing well? Yes. My personal theory is that incomes for middle class Americans really haven't increased since the 90s by much but incomes for Upper Middle Class to straight up wealthy Americans have increased a lot. However, the cost of living has gone way up and the middle class is feeling it more. As where the Upper Middle Class and Upper Class incomes have increased much faster than inflation, that they are thriving and feel like today is better.
document fetched 2026-10-09 00:46 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1x0wi4h/is_it_safe_to_say_the_economy_of_the_90s_was