Can you legally ban AI-assisted clean room cloning in a SaaS Terms of Service?
retained text
Now that AI agents can build functional clones just by looking at app screenshots or screen recordings, clean room copying has become way too easy. Because copyright doesn't protect pure functionality or ideas, traditional clean-room rebuilds don't trigger IP infringement. But what if you explicitly ban it in your ToS? Something like: *"You cannot use screenshots, UI workflows, or app content to prompt AI models to replicate our features."* A couple of questions for anyone familiar with SaaS law or IP: * Does contract law let you restrict things that are otherwise legal under copyright? * If someone logs in, takes screenshots, and hands the spec to a separate team that never agreed to the ToS, can you even go after the clone app? Or just the person who broke the terms? * Has anyone actually tried enforcing a clause like this yet?
document fetched 2026-11-02 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xl9ofk/can_you_legally_ban_aiassisted_clean_room_cloning