← sources

IFRS 16 is ridiculous and makes financial statements much less useful. Agree or disagree?

source: reddit (reddit:Accounting)published 2026-09-25 07:28ingested 2026-09-26 02:35

retained text

So the way IFRS 16 messes with leases is utterly ridiculous, and makes financial statements so much more useless. I'm not sure who thought that making this update somehow makes things 
clearer. Seems like a scheme to hide costs below EBITDA. 

Our company isn't one where lease expenses are a considerable part of the cost base, so it kind of flew under the radar until just recently. We started analyising the profitability of one small division where rental / lease costs are a considerable part of the cost base. It was only here I realised how ridiculous IFRS 16 is. 


My reasoning is this:

* Rental / lease costs are considered by most management teams as a part of your fixed cost base. But when we tried to get the EBITDA of this division, it somehow seemed strangely better than we expected. Of course this was because as we found out, these costs were hidden between a depreciation line and an interest cost line. However even that isn't equal to the actual rental payments, although they even out over time, in any particular time period your actual rental cost isn't what's going through the P&L. Meaning that to get your "true" cost, you can't even add up these two lines but have to go somewhere completely outside the accounting system to find the figure. 

* It then creates a lease liability on your balance sheet. OK, I can sort of appreciate this, but then there are lots of other agreements a company may enter into that create similar payment obligations, but those are ignored. Meaning its a meaningless figure. 

* It also creates a completely meaningless right of use asset. If you generally look at a balance sheet and use it as some rough approximation of what you might be able to liquidate the company's assets for (and yes book value can be very different from actual realisable proceeds), then a right of use asset is not something you can sell, but its just something the accountants dreamt up. 

So in short what we get from IFRS 16: hiding costs, creating a meaningless asset and an arbitrarily shown liability. 

What on earth were they thinking when they came up with this?

document fetched 2026-09-26 00:17 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1wppyos/ifrs_16_is_ridiculous_and_makes_financial