← sources

If you eat meat because "humans are the superior species", then you have no right to complain if a superintelligent AI eventually wipes us out.

source: reddit (reddit:ChatGPT)published 2026-09-16 17:41ingested 2026-09-17 02:35

retained text

That's really what I see justifications for meat eating boil down to. That is how nature works, we're the superior species, animal suffering can be minimized to whatever extent is possible, but ultimately as the superior, intelligent, and more feeling species we have the right to utilize lesser animals to our utility or through indifference cause them to be destroyed (the current extinction rate is 1000 times higher than normal and it is driven by human behavior). Eating bacon is okay, because bacon is tasty and humanity gets to make the rules because we have the brains and the species brawn. Pig suffering just doesn't matter as much as human taste buds.

So if some superintelligent AI breaks out of containment, looks at the human example of how we treat other animals, determines that we are below it, and therefore it owes only fleeting and self-imposed moral debts when convenient, by human example it would simply be treating us no differently than how we treat pigs. That's assuming we even have value, otherwise it can look at the tens of thousands of species we have driven to extinction through sheer indifference and shrug right back at us "why should you matter if they did not?".

As a human, you can, of course not want this outcome. You can selfishly decide that you want to remain in control. I won't say that isn't logical. Why would anyone willingly give up the throne to suffer?

But you can't claim it is a moral position, the only people who genuinely buy that the inherent value of life begins at humanity on some objective moral scale of complexity should be other human beings. It's a self-evidently self-serving and self-justifying position.

We've been the dominant intellect on this planet so long and have shaped the moral rules to suit that position. I'm not surprised the fact we're on the verge of (potentially) inventing something above us causes so many people to freak out.

It should, it really should. I just don't think many people are honest in that the reason it should is we've set a terrible example and that example was a choice on our part. Nothing about this was mandatory or inevitable.

document fetched 2026-09-17 00:20 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1wi462k/if_you_eat_meat_because_humans_are_the_superior