← sources

Please explain to me like I'm 5 what I'm doing wrong ( shipping )

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-23 10:32ingested 2026-09-24 02:37

retained text

I've spent hours scouring the internet for what seemed like a simple answer but I'm not getting it so I'm turning to my fellow Etsy sellers.  I've looked at other Reddit posts with the same problem but for some reasons none of those fixes seem to work for me.

On orders of single to a few stickers, I offer free shipping.  In the past I've always just sent them via hand-addressed letter mail with a Forever stamp and there's never been a problem.

I've decided to try using Etsy's labels for this just for the benefit of the buyer having the free tracking on the letter, but no matter how I set up the label, Etsy won't remove the non-machinable fee.  I even went to USPS official website and duplicated the same exact letter dimensions and thickness and etc. and USPS offers me the label WITHOUT the fee.  Only of course, they don't offer tracking.  So at that point I might as well just go right back to hand-addressed letters and my booklet of stamps.

I'd really like to send it via Etsy just so the customer has the free tracking, but I have no idea why Etsy keeps adding on the non-machinable fee despite my letter meeting all requirements.  Am I just entering something wrong?

document fetched 2026-09-24 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wo29rl/please_explain_to_me_like_im_5_what_im_doing