NCW owns 6 Cars but also hires 2 more — ₹1.59 lakh every month just for the rented vehicles
retained text
The responses provide some interesting numbers. 🚗 6 VEHICLES OWNED BY NCW The RTI says NCW currently owns 6 official vehicles. These include multiple Maruti Suzuki Ciaz/Dzire vehicles. 🚘 BUT NCW ALSO HIRES 2 ADDITIONAL VEHICLES 1. Toyota Innova HyCross Monthly charge: ₹1,15,530 2. Maruti Suzuki Ertiga Monthly charge: ₹43,800 TOTAL: ₹1,59,330 PER MONTH That's approximately: ₹19.12 LAKH PER YEAR just for the two hired vehicles. And this is separate from fuel and maintenance expenses for the vehicles owned by NCW. ⛽ FUEL A separate RTI provides yearly fuel consumption for the 6 owned vehicles. Total reported fuel consumption: 8,686 litres The RTI specifically says: "Monthly data is not maintained." The vehicle-wise figures were: • DL-1CAC-8632 — 1,485 litres • DL-1CAC-5410 — 1,765 litres • DL-3CDE-5000 — 1,726 litres • DL-10CQ-5000 — 125 litres • DL-4CAU-4001 — 1,650 litres • DL-3CCY-0416 — 1,935 litres 🔧 MAINTENANCE Vehicle-wise maintenance expenditure reported: • ₹46,726 • ₹81,634 • ₹92,494 • ₹42,014 • ₹55,738 • ₹1,14,041 Total: ₹4,32,647 📊 AND HERE'S THE INTERESTING PART The second RTI specifically asked NCW: Why are two additional vehicles being hired when NCW already owns six official vehicles? The RTI was made specifically to obtain the justification for this arrangement, along with fuel consumption, odometer readings, maintenance expenses, insurance/fitness records and accident/traffic challan information. There is also information showing that NCW has: • 3 vehicles for exclusive use • 3 vehicles in the common vehicle pool So the question isn't whether an organisation needs vehicles for official work. The reasonable taxpayer question is: If NCW already owns 6 vehicles, what operational requirement justifies hiring 2 additional vehicles at ₹1.59 lakh every month? ₹19.12 lakh a year is being spent on those two rentals alone. And that's before considering fuel, maintenance, drivers and other vehicle-related expenses. All figures above are taken from the NCW RTI replies. What do you think — is this level of vehicle expenditure justified by the organisation's requirements?
document fetched 2026-10-04 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1wwe0vk/ncw_owns_6_cars_but_also_hires_2_more_159_lakh