← sources

Would you cancel a marketing contract after their blog posts promised customers a warranty I don't offer?

source: reddit (reddit:smallbusiness)published 2026-10-09 13:27ingested 2026-10-10 02:36

retained text

I make leather wallets and card holders in my garage and sell them on my own website. Most things are $60 to $120. A normal month is around $13k in sales and I keep maybe half after materials and my one part time helper. Three years in, it's my only income.

In May a marketing company called and said they write blog posts for small online stores and it usually pays for itself in three or four months. I signed for six months in mid June at $1,400 a month, billed on the 15th. The contract says eight posts a month and a monthly report. They publish straight to my site and I never checked what went up.

Yesterday a woman emailed asking me to replace her wallet under my lifetime warranty. We don't have one, it's two years. She sent a screenshot of ChatGPT saying we do, and when I looked, one of the blog posts they wrote for me says the exact same thing. My helper was standing next to me and just said "so we're paying them for this?" I went through the rest of the posts and found another one about a brown color I stopped making in the spring.

Their reports keep saying visits are up, and they are, but I'm getting the same 150 or so orders a month I had before I signed. The report lists the most visited posts and they're things like how to clean leather boots or fix a jacket.

I told the company and they said they'd edit the posts, and that the contract covers writing and rankings, not sales. I know I should have read it closer. I just heard "pays for itself" and stopped listening. I haven't gone through the cancellation part yet.

I've paid four months so far, so $5,600, and I have two left right before the gift season. Would you try to get out of this contract?

document fetched 2026-10-10 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1x1lcup/would_you_cancel_a_marketing_contract_after_their