← sources

FNMA & FMCC: Why the hold-up?

source: reddit (reddit:wallstreetbets)published 2026-11-17 21:06ingested 2026-11-18 02:40

retained text

TL;DR: Fannie and Freddie have already paid the Treasury substantially more than the government originally provided. Their profits are being retained, but the SPS LP continues to hang over the ownership structure. If Trump deems the SPS repaid, I see potential for 5x gains from current prices, if not more. If Treasury maintains its claim, common shareholders could get destroyed.

The entire FNMA/FMCC investment thesis comes down to the Senior Preferred Stock and its associated liquidation preference (SPS LP). Contrary to what many people believe, Fannie and Freddie aren’t currently sending their profits back to the government. Their earnings are being retained within the companies, while the SPS LP grows.

Two possible outcomes:  
1) Treasury affirms the SPS LP. Common shareholders could be left with very little. Low single digits or worse.  
2) Trump/Treasury deem the SPS repaid or otherwise resolve the claim favourably. My estimates are 5x from current price levels, if not more than that. And that’s after accounting for Treasury warrant exercise and dilution.

Bessent has indicated that the administration intends to address the ownership structure in 2027 or 2028. Treasury’s warrants expire in September 2028. Trump has an opportunity to deliver a significant policy achievement before leaving office, and resolving the GSE situation could be one of them. Remember, his administration ended the Net Worth Sweep in September 2019 without an extended public campaign announcing the decision beforehand. Could we see another surprise announcement? 🤔

Trump’s Executive Order 14393, signed March 13, 2026, instructed FHFA to examine the housing finance market and recommend regulatory or legislative changes. One potential catalyst is a reduction in the Enterprise Regulatory Capital Framework (ERCF). Based on my calculations, the Twins are approximately $120B short of required CET1 capital, including buffers. That’s four to five years of earnings. Some bulls suggest a reduction to 2.5%, but the work required to action that could take months. Fortunately for us, the SPS decision is separate from ERCF rule-making and could potentially happen much sooner.

Credit quality is deteriorating. The Twins are expanding their multi-family businesses despite growing signs of housing market stress.

A few Q1 2026 figures:  
\- Freddie Mac multi-family business up 24% year-over-year to $12.8bn.  
\- Fannie’s average new loan increased from $18m to $26m.  
\- Full interest-only loans increased from 54% to 68%.  
\- Fannie’s multi-family serious delinquencies up 48% since December 2023.  
\- Multifamily write-offs increased from $61m to $243m year-over-year.

The May ABS-15G filings revealed another interesting problem. According to my analysis, Fannie successfully resolved approximately 38% of submitted repurchase demands, while Freddie managed just 3%. These demands relate to defective loans involving fraud or misrepresentation. Not exactly encouraging management performance. The longer conservatorship continues, the greater the risk of institutional deterioration and worsening credit conditions.

**What should Trump do?**  
\- Resolve the SPS, ideally deeming it repaid.  
\- Uplist to a major stock exchange (the NYSE).  
\- Address the remaining capital requirements and exit conservatorship in a controlled manner thereafter. 

I see FNMA & FMCC as an enormous asymmetric political bet with massive upside if the SPS is resolved favourably, but potentially catastrophic downside if it isn’t. Bessent has pointed towards 2027–28, with the warrants expiring in September 2028. After running out of time in his first Presidency, Trump won’t make that same mistake again, right? 🚀 

document fetched 2026-11-18 00:35 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/1xyw8qh/fnma_fmcc_why_the_holdup