We spent 25k on Seedance and kling APIs for 3 months to swap actors and keep delicate motion and it all failed big time.
retained text
As the main developer, i am so, so angry at this company (Bytedance). I mean, we pay them 1400 a month to be able to add real faces, on top of that around 10 USD for a 60 seconds 720p video, we tested EVERY single trick in the book and we can NOT make it swap an actor. **I am not talking normal swap, but one with delicate actions, different angles, small details etc.**
Imagine a woman front camera illustrate something she is doing, makeup, hair style, whatever, with delicate actions and order. We just wanted to replace her with another model of ours (registered on Seedance so no face problems).
We tried EVERYTHING. On Edit mode("Edit Video 1 etc"), it will simply not replace the model, it can replace anything else. Their support are useless and didn't even had an idea that there is edit mode and new movie mode. We tried sophisticated 3d modeling, first frame, blur face, what ever you can imagine. God knows why this company decided you can replace everything but a person (no, its not safety issue, we pay and have Rights to do so etc).
So edit mode is gone, now if you ask it a new movie, it will obviously replace the main actress but you have to describe every single action happens in the video in words (using Gemini), and then if you are lucky you get 60% accuracy. (because its not a real edit, but just a new generation).
Kling 4- is pretty much garbage, we spent also like 3k on this, not only the quality is a joke, while it will replace the actress, it is just not copying the original motion even if its on edit mode (Base video rather than reference video). Output looks like plastic compared with seedance.
I mean, am I stupid ? or these guys just want us to spend on tokens?
It seems like the models CAN do it(new movIe mode does copy parts of the movie correctly but lose order and invent shit, and edit mode allow to literally replace anything else you like), but for some reason they don't want you to do this easily, even if you are a large company who take responsibility for copyrights and pay them.
Help?document fetched 2026-11-12 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/generativeAI/comments/1xtt40w/we_spent_25k_on_seedance_and_kling_apis_for_3