← sources

A very balanced and non biased take on resignation of Gyanesh Kumar

source: reddit (reddit:india)published 2026-10-19 09:06ingested 2026-10-20 02:37

retained text

These protests are irrational and unreasonable. Im not saying anti-national but irrational and unreasonable. See gyanesh Kumar is chief election commissioner of india. A post protected by constitution. That cannot be removed by just anyone just because they feel like it not even by pm. There is a need of substantial, legally credible evidence that is generally essential to remove India's Chief Election Commissioner or Under Article 324(5) of the Constitution, removal requires proved misbehaviour or incapacity. Accusations aren't enough. Plus evidence alone is not enough. Even if serious evidence exists, removal still requires the parliamentary supermajorities in both Houses. Conversely, a motion can be rejected before a full inquiry takes place. So the prime minister himself can't demand cec resignation until the above process is completed. He can't be removed just because a big mob is gathered protesting on accusations it's called mobocracy not democracy. All opposition ministers need to submit substantial evidence and perform the process in parliament to make gyanesh Kumar. Protest and the government itself can't do a shit. So everyday if someone gathered a big mob just because they don't like certain people in the government of india will be a mobocracy not a democracy. Right wing and left wing both can be wrong we need balance both to preserve the democracy neither letting go in fascist authotaranian rule or irrational anarchy. Plus my question is why the opposition leaders ain't submitting evidence .

document fetched 2026-10-20 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1x9rx5g/a_very_balanced_and_non_biased_take_on