← sources

Unable to create app password in Microsoft?

source: reddit (reddit:sysadmin)published 2026-10-05 17:23ingested 2026-10-06 02:40

retained text

EDIT: much appreciated, everyone. My initial belief was correct, legacy auth wasn't the way to go and we'd just be kneecapping our security and making life harder down the road. Super is going to submit a quote for setting up a relay instead. Thanks all!  


TL;DR: Microsoft security settings *should* be set properly to create an app password for a client's outdated SMTP tool, but the option doesn't expose itself. Users in tenant that previously were able to create app passwords still have valid passwords, but cannot create new ones.

\+++++++++

Unsure of what to do here. I have been going back and forth with PAX 8 for a couple weeks now, haven't gotten anywhere with them and they only respond with AI-generated questions to things I've already answered.

Client uses a mailing app for their clientele that relies on authenticating with an app password. Contacted vendor, they don't currently support OAuth and at least as of right now, there's no plans on the roadmap. It's a church administration software with a mailing list function, fairly niche for their use case so we don't have a ton of options.

I previously set a couple of this client's users up with app passwords, we haven't had any problems with the existing app passwords. Curiously, though we didn't change anything with these users' accounts, their app passwords are still present in Security Info but they can't create a new one.

Our main issue is they hired a new admin who needs an account set up for this app, which of course requires an app password. I replicated the settings and setup I documented the first go round, but it won't expose the option for a new app password.

I dug through MS documentation and forums, no luck. The documented prerequisites are all satisfied:

* Security Defaults set to Disabled
* Tenant setting “Allow users to create app passwords to sign in to non-browser apps” set to Enabled
* Affected users have per-user MFA enforced
* MFA registration is complete
* Microsoft Authenticator is registered
* No Conditional Access policy is blocking legacy authentication for the affected users
* The users can access Security Info normally
* App password does not appear under Security Info > Add sign-in method

Not sure if I'm missing something or not. The easy solution here is an SMTP relay service (which, being a church, they could probably get for cheap or free) and I'll be researching some options for it, but my super recommended I post here to get more eyes on it. Still digging through Michaelsoft's documentation as well, to see if I'm just dumb or there's a hidden setting.

document fetched 2026-10-06 00:35 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1wyehvu/unable_to_create_app_password_in_microsoft