← sources

Take management role at a sinking ship or bounce?

source: reddit (reddit:sales)published 2026-10-29 21:56ingested 2026-10-30 02:38

retained text

Here’s my situation. I’m a new sales rep at a small software company. I joined because it offered a decent bump in both base salary and OTE. When I joined, I was told that even though the company had been around for eight years, it still operates like a startup, so you need to be comfortable with ambiguity, a lack of structure, and a little chaos to be successful.


Cool. I have five years of software sales experience, specifically selling to their ICP, so I feel pretty comfortable with that.


What I didn’t realize is that nobody is hitting quota. Team attainment is sitting around 25%, which is obviously pretty abysmal. Hand up, that's on me for not confirming during the interview process.


After a couple of months, I’m starting to realize that the problem goes beyond sales execution. The product hasn’t really kept up with the market and the company doesn’t seem to be making meaningful investments in the product or marketing. Competitors have better features, are easier to use, and in many cases are cheaper. The general approach seems to be, “Here’s what we’ve got. Go out and see if you can sell it."

Now my manager has decided to leave, and because I have the most sales experience on the team, particularly with this ICP, I’m being asked to consider stepping into the management role.

The catch? My individual quota would stay exactly the same. I’d just be adding coaching, weekly one-on-ones, helping the reps improve their prospecting, demos, and closing, and trying to influence product and marketing along the way.

Part of me finds that really exciting. I like the idea of building a sales process, developing reps, and helping create more structure in an otherwise chaotic environment. It could be a great opportunity to develop my leadership skills and get a management title on my resume.

But I also can’t shake the feeling that this is a hopeless, sinking ship.

Sales been declining for the past five years, and churn is at a historical high. From what I can see, the product is falling further behind competitors, and I’m not convinced that better sales execution alone is going to solve the problem.

There’s a lot of pressure to improve the team’s prospecting, demos, and closing. Those are all things that can absolutely be improved. But even if we get better at all of them, can we realistically expect to quadruple sales anytime soon to hit quota?

That’s ultimately what I’m struggling with. I was making more money at my previous job, even with a lower base salary, because I was selling successfully. This move has effectively been a pay cut, and now I have the opportunity to take on more responsibility without necessarily the promise of any additional money since sales at so low. 

So what would you do in this situation?

Would you take the management title, treat it as a learning opportunity, and try to make the most of it while knowing the company might have a pretty limited runway? I'm talking like, 6 - 9 months. (The VP of Sales has already said they'll probably cut one of the other two sales reps this quarter, so that doesn't give me confidence.)

Or would you start looking for another job now, before investing more time and energy into a company that may not be able to turn things around?

Has anyone been in a similar situation, where you believe you can improve the sales team but aren’t convinced the product or the business itself is set up to succeed? How did you approach it?

document fetched 2026-10-30 00:29 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sales/comments/1xixhq1/take_management_role_at_a_sinking_ship_or_bounce