Income Tax demand reconciliation + ₹6.72 lakh penalty under Section 270A — CA quoting ₹65k fees plus alleged bribe. Need advice.
retained text
Hi everyone, I need advice regarding an income-tax matter for AY 2024–25. I’d appreciate input from people who have dealt with similar cases or tax professionals. **Background:** I filed my ITR for AY 2024–25 declaring total income of approximately ₹14.43 lakh. I had claimed a deduction of ₹10.78 lakh under Section 80GGC for a political donation. During scrutiny, I withdrew the deduction and paid ₹4.15 lakh in November 2025, following discussions with the investigation officer. An assessment order under Section 143(3) was passed on 16 February 2026. I have now received a penalty order dated 21 September 2026 under Section 270A, imposing a penalty of ₹6,72,680 for alleged misreporting of income. I had submitted a response to the penalty show-cause notice, but the department rejected my arguments. **There is also an issue with the outstanding demand displayed on the income-tax portal.** The portal shows two entries for AY 2024–25: ₹2,55,140 ₹1,29,920 Both appear to have the same demand reference number, assessment section (143(3)), demand date and response date. I had previously paid ₹4.15 lakh, so I want to understand whether the payment has been correctly credited and whether these entries represent duplicate or separate demands. **My CA has quoted the following:** ₹15,000 for demand reconciliation. An additional unofficial payment/bribe, allegedly to get the demand corrected. ₹50,000 for filing an appeal before CIT(A) against the penalty order. I understand that the appeal may involve substantial legal work, but I am unsure whether these charges are reasonable and whether the reconciliation can be handled through the official portal. **My questions:** How can I verify whether my ₹4.15 lakh payment has been properly credited against the assessment demand? If two demand entries have the same reference number, how do I establish whether this is a duplicate entry or a portal display issue? Can I submit a demand reconciliation or correction request myself, or is professional representation necessary? Is ₹50,000 a reasonable professional fee for a CIT(A) appeal against a Section 270A penalty of ₹6.72 lakh? What are the legal grounds that may be worth examining in an appeal when a deduction was withdrawn during scrutiny and the additional tax was paid? Is there any official reason to make an unofficial payment to get a demand reconciled? I am uncomfortable with this suggestion. Would you recommend getting a second opinion from a tax-litigation lawyer before proceeding? I want to resolve this through the proper legal process, avoid paying any duplicate demand, and understand my options before spending another ₹65,000 or more. Please share your experience or suggest the appropriate official procedure. Thanks! PS. Took help from AI to simplify
document fetched 2026-10-10 00:46 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1x17pkf/income_tax_demand_reconciliation_672_lakh_penalty