It’s not the government’s job to deliver equity returns.
retained text
​ There’s been a noticeable shift in some of these investing/equities/FD-related subs. Real discussion about valuations, opportunity cost, risk, and actual investing has been getting crowded out by a flood of highly active accounts that seem to exist only to push a simplistic “government vs equities” narrative. Many of these accounts post at a volume that suggests Reddit is their full-time job. The net effect is less signal, more noise, and a growing pretense that everything is fine at the macro level. A few reminders that keep getting lost: It is \*\*not\*\* the government’s job to generate returns for your mutual funds, stocks, or equity SIPs. That risk is the entire point of the asset class. You take equity risk precisely because there is no guarantee. The government’s actual responsibility on the financial side is narrower and more important: keep the banking system solvent, prevent systemic collapse, and maintain reasonable macroeconomic stability. Those are not the same thing as underwriting your portfolio’s CAGR. I recently saw a funny post claiming people will shift to FDs and stay away from equities until the government changes. The irony is almost perfect because ensuring that Fixed Deposits actually deliver (i.e., that banks remain solvent and depositors are protected) is very much the government’s job. Equity returns are not. Conflating the two is how we end up with confused conversations. The current macro backdrop is not as benign as some of the cheerleading suggests. We are in an environment where several natural-resource-rich nations are not primarily trading , they are at war or under severe geopolitical stress. Input prices have been volatile and, in many cases, elevated. Managing crude and containing inflation remains the real day-to-day challenge for policymakers. Layer on top of that: \- US government debt service costs hitting levels not seen in generations \- Central bank policy becoming more reactive and less predictable These are not minor footnotes. They affect cost of capital, risk premia, and the opportunity set for equity investors everywhere, including India. Not long ago these subs used to function as places where people looked for mispricings, debated actual numbers, and mined opportunities. That version was more useful. The current version : where large amounts of bandwidth go into defending or attacking the government as if that were the primary driver of equity returns ; is a downgrade. Equity investing has always been about underwriting risk in exchange for potential excess returns. That risk does not disappear because of political narratives, and it is not the government’s mandate to remove it. Treating it as if it were is a category error, and the volume of accounts currently dedicated to reinforcing that error is not helping the conversation.
document fetched 2026-10-05 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1wxk3tv/its_not_the_governments_job_to_deliver_equity