← sources

Looking For Payroll Service Recommendations for Highly Seasonal Employee Counts

source: reddit (reddit:smallbusiness)published 2026-11-17 03:18ingested 2026-11-18 02:39

retained text

Like the title said, I'm looking for payroll service recommendations and I'm having some trouble because the company I work for is kind of in a weird space so I'm not seeing advice that's directly relevant to our situation. The things we need to consider are:

\- Approximately 15 year-round people who need payroll, 5 of whom are partners as opposed to W-2 employees. Generally stable and the same people, but hours vary from part time to overtime, depending on the time of year. Most are getting paid hourly but two are effectively salaried.

\- Anywhere from 1 to 60 extra employees who are on the books for anywhere between 1 and 8 weeks at a time, who are hourly W-2 + commission salespeople at events. Only one event has 60 extra employees, most of the year it's between 1 and 5 extra people + a couple of the regular hourly employees also doing sales so getting commission on their sales hours.

\- Located in California, but we have two events out of state, one in Oregon and one in Washington. Most of our employees for those events are traveling California employees, but we have occasionally needed to hire a local if something happens last minute.

\- It would be a big bonus if they did healthcare broker services too, because we'd like to offer it but absolutely won't get it done without something streamlining this.

I've used ADP before, managing a different small business, and had an awful experience with them doing partner pay incorrectly and it was such a giant pain to deal with when it came to light. I transitioned that business to Gusto after that and I really liked them, but that was about 7 years ago and for a business with 5 employees, so I'm not sure if Gusto's current offerings/support level are correct for what we're working with now. Currently, we do payroll manually with a spreadsheet, so options that aren't that would be great. Any recommendations, thoughts, or advice about this situation are greatly appreciated!

Edit: a word/grammar

document fetched 2026-11-18 00:31 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1xy9pfi/looking_for_payroll_service_recommendations_for