← sources

How do you do ads?

source: reddit (reddit:ecommerce)published 2026-11-07 07:39ingested 2026-11-08 02:36

retained text

So past month, we've been sending out lashes (our niche) to creators to make videos. We sell them at around $16 a set. We've been asking them to make GRWM videos or showcase videos. This is also what a lot of our competitors are doing. [Ninetynine Dreams ad library](https://www.facebook.com/ads/library/?active_status=active&ad_type=all&country=US&is_targeted_country=false&media_type=all&search_type=page&sort_data[direction]=desc&sort_data[mode]=total_impressions&view_all_page_id=106102395705911). There are a few other ones that also do these types of videos and as far as I can tell, these work pretty well for them. They also have videos talking about the lashes as well, but the most common ones are GRWM and showcase videos. There is this other brand where a lot of their videos actually have substance in it: [Kulan Beauty ad library](https://www.facebook.com/ads/library/?active_status=active&ad_type=all&country=US&is_targeted_country=false&media_type=all&search_type=page&sort_data[direction]=desc&sort_data[mode]=total_impressions&view_all_page_id=445160728669610). They actually talk in their videos.

We've been running ads on our videos for the past few weeks on $150 spend and have been getting 1-2 sales a day. Our current set up is Advantage+ off (it used to be on but it kept pushing it to older women with insanely high CPMs, also barely any sales). Our CTR is about 1% and CPM more than $25.

Questions we’re stuck on:

* Content format: For a visual beauty product like lashes, what actually converts? GRWM, showcase/try-on, talking head with B-roll, or voiceover over B-roll?
* Picking what to run: How do you decide which organic or creator videos are worth running as ads? Do you go by organic views, watch time, a gut call on the hook, or just test everything?
* Hooks: Most of our creator videos don’t really have a hook. They start with the creator holding the box or getting ready. Is it worth re-editing them (lash close-up first, text hook on screen), or do we need to brief creators to film hooks from the start?
* Voice: Voiceover over B-roll, or a talking head with B-roll cut in? Does having someone actually talk matter for a product people buy mostly on looks?
* How to sell it: This isn’t a supplement or a problem-solution product where you can explain benefits for 60 seconds. It’s mostly “does it look good on me.” How do you sell something that’s mostly visual and emotional? Is it just volume of good-looking try-ons, or do you need an angle, like “glueless, no bond and seal, easier on your natural lashes”?
* What’s working for others: Competitors like \[Ninetynine Dreams\] (linked above) mostly run GRWM and showcase ads that seem to do well, while \[Kulan Beauty\] runs ads where the creator actually talks about the product. Which approach tends to work better for a newer brand without brand recognition?
* Campaign setup: How would you set up campaigns at our budget?
   * Testing: ABO with one ad set per creative or per angle, or CBO with everything in one ad set and letting Meta pick?
   * Ad count: How many ads per ad set, and how much should each spend before we kill or keep it?
   * Targeting: Broad / Advantage+ audience, or a defined audience like women 18–34? Ours is narrow right now and CPM is high.
   * Optimization: Optimize for purchases from day one, or for add to cart until the pixel has more data?
   * Scaling: When a creative wins, do we move it into an Advantage+ Shopping / scale campaign, or raise the budget where it is?
   * Budget: What daily budget is realistic to actually learn something at a \~$16 product?

I don't expect anyone to have direct answers and I know I should have thought of all this prior, but I did and thought my answers were right. But now actually doing it, it seems like I was wrong. Our ads also don't feel like ads just boring GRWM/influencer videos. Any advice and reply will be much appreciated.

document fetched 2026-11-08 00:22 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1xq0omi/how_do_you_do_ads