Hosting email: Still trouble after a year or so. Help?
retained text
Note: I am aware there have been quite a few email posts recently. Sorry to clutter your feed! My Proton subscription is coming to an end this month, so I'm looking to move full-time to my selfhosted server. My emails are still landing in spam on Gmail and Outlook. These are the details: * Hosted on a Hetzner VPS with a static IPv4 that isn't on any public blocklists * Port 25 and 465 are unlocked (you need to wait for that with Hetzner). They're obviously not the only ones that are forwarded. * Stalwart v1.0 server * 10/10 on mail-tester and any similar service I could find * My DKIM, DMARC, SPF and rPTR are all fine * I've tried `none` and `reject` DMARC policies, didn't make a difference. It's currently set to none as some Google forum said to do that. * Domain (porkbun, cf nameservers) is about a year old, just like the server * Haven't done much in terms of ip-warming, but I've been marked as not spam on both Gmail and Outlook by \~5 people * The server has one user: me (and I'm fairly certain I haven't sent out any spam) * I do not allow relaying * I linked my domain to the google postmaster tools (shows nothing, despite having sent some emails back and forth with a few gmail users) and whatever the MS equivalent is called, which has no useful data either. * I currently do not have DNSSEC but I could look into it. **I'm not interested in using an SMTP relay**, as it somewhat defeats the purpose. I'd have given up a long time ago if it wasn't for the fact that half the comments on most email threads I've read are claiming it's fine for them. I just don't know what I'm doing wrong. Is it just the IP? Should I request a new one/move to a different provider?
document fetched 2026-11-02 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1xl53yy/hosting_email_still_trouble_after_a_year_or_so