409a massively overvalues shares (and company?) i will not promote
retained text
Working at a startup with a 409a valuation that keeps going up a bit each year raising the FMV the employee common equity modestly. Option strike price when I started was $1 then FMV a year later was $1.50 and a year later $2.05 and so on. All makes sense. Problem is software company (SaaS) valuations have absolutely plummeted and are now being sold for 2-4 x ARR (vs 10-15 x ARR in the before times) which puts the company at a fraction of the common stock implied FMV valuation. I spoke with company financial people and they say the 409a is based on 3-year average growth rates and 10-15x sales multiple but: 1. the current year growth is much lower than 2 years ago 2. 10-15 sales multiple is way way higher than what SaaS companies are being acquired for now Can 409 a valuations be dramatically mis-priced like this? In this case, the 409a suggests the company to be worth almost 10 times a reasonable ARR multiple in today's market using comparable company sales/acquisitions
document fetched 2026-09-13 00:31 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/startups/comments/1wei1fd/409a_massively_overvalues_shares_and_company_i