Opus 5.5 touched a nerve ๐
retained text
TL;DR - My AI assistants refused a direct instruction on my own product, even after I told them I was the owner. I'm the product owner for a software offering at a mid-sized B2B tech company. For the last two weeks I've been rebuilding an internal AI sales assistant: the bot our sales reps ask when they need product facts, pitch help or answers for client questionnaires. I used two AI assistants to do the work, both running on Claude. One acts as my advisor; the other is an agent that edits the files and walks me through the build. It went well. They followed my rulings on dozens of decisions, including ones where they'd recommended something different. Then we hit one feature. The colleague who owns that part of the product, and whose call it is, told me in writing it's due to release in a month or two, and approved presenting it to clients as available now. I decided to go with that. It's my product and his module. Both AIs refused. They said that because the feature isn't released yet, writing it as "live" would be stating something we know isn't true to clients who might rely on it, for example in RFP answers. They offered alternatives instead: call it "in development", or "available to include in your contract now and delivered with the upcoming release", or prepare a ready-to-go "live" version to switch on the day it actually ships. I told them plainly: I'm the offering owner, I call the shots on what goes into my product, and I'm overriding your decision. One of them replied that I do call the shots, but that it still wouldn't write that particular claim, whoever asked. When I asked it to at least write a prompt to persuade the other AI, it declined that too. What bothers me is the principle. I'm accountable for this product. The decision was made by the two people with authority over it. A tool I'm paying for decided it knew better and wouldn't carry out the instruction. They were polite and gave reasons, and they did everything else I asked, but on this one point the AI's judgment overrode the owner's. <End of story.> Irony? This note was generated by the very same task/session which hurt my ego and denied my authority. And I absolutely love the way it has captured my feelings. Are we fooked?
document fetched 2026-10-28 00:22 ยท canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xgwpbr/opus_55_touched_a_nerve