What do you think about fully open review systems? [D]
retained text
In the age of AI, I believe the era in which individuals can dominate others solely on the basis of background knowledge, theoretical expertise, academic affiliation, or reputation is coming to an end. If we move from a double-blind review process to a fully open review system, it would become significantly more difficult to present false or misleading claims as established facts. Moreover, even under the current double-blind system, there is a tendency to favor papers from close-knit academic communities, as authorship can often be inferred by tracking preprints on platforms such as arXiv. I believe that a fully open review system could help mitigate this form of bias as well. Ultimately, such a system could also help address the overwhelming volume of both AI-generated submissions and AI-generated review comments by increasing transparency and accountability throughout the review process.
document fetched 2026-09-26 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1wq93m0/what_do_you_think_about_fully_open_review_systems