Why GOLD FELL and Where is it Heading!
retained text
Gold shouldn't had fallen: 1. Bond Yields fell 12BPS in a single day, meaning as per calculation gold should rise by 1.7% but fell by 2.2% that day 2. China bought highest level of gold this sept 13T which is highest in last 3 years 3. Our festive season is booming and demand is high aswell Still gold fell! meaning someone was dumping gold! Historically this has happened before- 21st Oct 2025 - Drops 5.5% and bounce back 2020 - Drops 12% and bounce back 2008 - Drops 30% and bounce right back (exception 2013 where gold kept falling 25%+ and didn't recover in short term) Soo this time is it a shakeout or an actual bear market for gold?? My Understanding (soo what happened): The real potential traders are- 1. Rate Hike Bettors (betting on another rate hike) Rate Hike Bettors are the ones Reuters (news reporters) are blaming, but fed rate didn't rise and 2-year yield fell soo they were betting on fewer hikes. They knew. 3. Oil Importers (selling oil for dollars) Usually oil importers like India, China selling whatever they can to pump dollar in market to secure oil. But the dollar index barely moved and there was normal to low volatility in the dollar trading aswell. Also China being the biggest imported, didn't pump in dollars as yuan was strong against dollar, in fact highest in 4 years 5. Hedge Funds (betting with borrowed money) These are big boys, the professional traders. America's futures regulator CFTC publishes weekly report on gold bets under a section called ''managed money'', soo these hedge funds basically bet borrowed money for futures of gold in NYSE. Yesterday when gold fell banks would ask for extra margin, that would reflect in today's report but it shows no sign, meaning they closed their positions and booked profits. These were the short-term speculative players, but when we see the long-term data, mainly the ETF Holding (where physically gold needs to be backed), as per World Gold Council data 4256T held till end of sept and last month this month was 37T more even when gold fell by +8% Soo what I understand that, as Nasdaq and Dow fell, their margin calls got active, and gold/silver/platinum being extremely liquid and like worlds atm it is easier to sell and save the margin money. And more over as gold is sitting on a fat +40% profit it is a no brainer to sell over to save guard the margins. And the long-term players mainly the central banks they kept their holdings steadily in an regular buying manner. (ex. China still bough 23T sept and 63T this Quarter bringing total of 2410T in total). The people who took the gold to $5000 where the these short term hedge funds / private money and speculators who vanish off as and when needed. You need to understand why people buy gold!? It is only and only for insurance and hedging, that protects you from inflation (for ex. gold in 1980 was $850 and with adjusting inflation today that should be $3900 meaning if someone gave you this gold down the line you would had made nothing) If we go back in history, after 1971, when dollar backing gold was paused, inflation started rising and gold rose from $35 to $850 by 1980, then fed stepped in and put Fed Interest Rates at max 20% shooting up the Real Yields % then gold fell for 2 decades. (this is like text book whenever >>Yield Rises -- Gold Falls <<) Since then the Central Bank of America bought trillions of dollars worth of gold throughout the years from the newly made money. Then in 2013 ETFs and future speculators sold 880T of Gold where Central Banks bought 330T but gold fell anyway as they were selling 2x of what was being bought. (keep this in mind....this is what worries me!) But then came 2022, which broke the Gold vs Yield relation, where yields kept rising from -1% to where it is now....which technically should had crushed gold prices, the opposite happened and gold went up from $1800 to $4000.......Why??!! Because of Russia, when the Russia-Ukraine war started, they froze their reserves that were kept in other countries, which all the central banks saw and learned! Then came the Great Global Central Banks buying of Gold! this frenzy also poured huge private money aswell (you me hedge-funds). Soo basically what happened, the levels >>Yields and Gold<< swing rose from $1800 levels to $4000. Gold basically moves when the system changes! \--1971 when dollar leaves gold \--1980 fed rate hike 20% \--2022 Russia reserves frozen Now, if you see both times when gold crashed, 2008 and 2020 it bottomed within weeks and bounced back because Fed came to the rescue by a) Flooding the World with Dollars b) Lending cheap dollar to other central banks c) cutting interest rates. But not this time! The Fed is raising rates and this time they hold the current 3.75-4% where 8 of them voted for hold and 2 to raise and none to reduce. You need to understand gold doesn't move on the Fed rates soo much than on the Real Yield (Yields - Inflation). Pay attention to what Fed Chairman said, they want price stability and inflation is high with economy expanding at higher pace, he clearly is NOT going to reduce rates anytime soon that's for sure. With only 1 meeting left (9th December) and with very Hot PCE Inflation that came 2 days back, it is very very likely the Fed is going to increase the Interest Rates on December......soo as per text book >>Yield Rises -- Gold Falls << Another interesting thing that happened was when the Fed was busy rate rising, the treasury was doing the Fed's job of buying back the long-term bonds (10-30 years) (they almost quadrupled their buying last 2 months, cash to bonds) to curb the yield rates....or so they liked to think! So what is the reason of the buy backs and why does America care soo much about them......see if you ++Interests ++Veterans Benefits ++Entitlements the US Govt. actually uses 89% off all Taxes it gets...and this percentage is growing in 2x!! Think like your salary is being eaten up by ++ home loans ++car loans ++insurances and you have barely anything left to buy your groceries...Soo that is the current situation of the US Govt. right now! Soo what I think -- The Treasury Holding Back the Bonds + High Inflation + Real Yield of Bonds fall and Bond-Holders loose interest + Hedge buyers go back to Gold But if the fixes work and US Bonds are Safer! then Gold Losses Next date to look for 4th November...when the treasury says the biggest buy backs carry on or not.... But India's story is different, even with peak demand coming soon, our gold always had the cushion and much safer than the raw us rates, in dollar rates gold fell 28% whereas in India it fell 21% because in India Gold is priced = $ Gold Price X Rupee + Import Duty. Recently the Import Duty got raised from 6% to 15%.....this is the cushion. Soo yes! If you are still here! Then yes! Gold may fall further!! Because if US Stocks fall > it will trigger margin calls > and the easiest liquid capital to sell is GOLD and that was the main reason why when Dow and Nasdaq crashed on Friday - - Gold was the 1st to get HIT!! and below that sits CRUDE because when that keeps rising > countries need to raise dollar > and the easiest liquid capital to sell is GOLD But that thing that worries me the most is the case study of 2013 that I mentioned earlier... ETF buyer kept buying the dips when gold started falling from 2011....and finally they cracked and started selling during 2013 which dropped the prices from $1900 to $1000 (45% drawdown)....that time real bond yields were giving 2.64% interest and 4 out of 5 investments were into bonds by major hedge funds... Soo the Question...if the ETF buyers become seller this time and consider historical drawdown on 45% then that makes gold at $3000 and with the Indian cushion I think that price comes close to Rs.120,000. And if you talk in technical analysis then that also comes close to the Head & Shoulder breakdown target. (check it yourselves) Soo you know what to do! I have pretty much though of most important angles while dealing with GOLD! If you are that person who can withstand and hold gold from coming 10 Years....you are GOLDEN! Stay buy the dips like usual! See gold has a nominal growth of 3% inflation with 2-3% real growth = 5-6% pa. Now if the AI thing works then Yields will rise and stay at 7-9% then gold will lag for years that we saw earlier..... Keep an eye on early Nov for Central Bank counts on how much gold they bought this quarter and Dhanteras+Diwali.....
document fetched 2026-11-01 00:41 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1xkhhpz/why_gold_fell_and_where_is_it_heading