← sources

TrueNAS vs Unraid vs ZimaOS for my home server

source: reddit (reddit:homelab)published 2026-10-27 22:59ingested 2026-10-28 02:38

retained text

Hey everyone, I'm building my first home server and trying to decide between **TrueNAS, Unraid, and ZimaOS**. OpenMediaVault is also an option I'm willing to consider, but those are my main three choices atm.

My hardware: Intel Core i5-10500 (using QuickSync), ASUS Prime B460M-A, 16 GB Non-ECC DDR4, 3x WD Red 4TB HDDs (WD40EFRX - CMR). I want to start with 1 parity/recovery disk so I get 8TB usable space and possibly add a 4th 4TB drive down the line to expand to 12TB usable. 

What I plan to run: Jellyfin (max \~3 simultaneous streams for family/friends), Immich (family photo/video backup), Arr stack (Sonarr, Radarr, Prowlarr, qBittorrent), Nextcloud (maybe down the road).

So here's my questions:

1. Which OS would you recommend?

Which of the options would be the best fit for these workloads, particularly in terms of ease of use, reliability, and long-term maintenance? One important consideration is expandability (but probably with a same size drive). My understanding was that TrueNAS makes this difficult because of how ZFS handles RAIDZ expansion, although I've read that RAIDZ expansion has recently become possible. How practical is it now to start with three drives and add a fourth later? My second preference would be ZimaOS. Is there any disadvantage to it for my use case? Or differences in terms of how safe the data is in case of a drive failure / restoration.

2. Performance and drive longevity

Are there meaningful differences between these options in terms of read/write performance for my use case? I'm also curious about how the storage configurations compare in terms of HDD wear. For example, would a ZFS-based setup put significantly more load on the drives compared to others or is this not important for light home server workload?

Anddd while we're here, also a few unrelated questions:

3. I bought all three WD Red drives used. 2 have 10k power-on hours and 1 \~30k. Before putting them into service, what tests should I run to check their health? Just an extended SMART self-test or something else?

4. Using the server as a VPN: The server will be put in a country where I won't be living permanently. I'd like to route my internet traffic through my home server sometimes so that websites see me as browsing from that country. Can I set up a VPN server on the NAS for this? Is Tailscale the appropriate choice for this?

Thanks in advance for any advice.

document fetched 2026-10-28 00:36 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1xh7m7z/truenas_vs_unraid_vs_zimaos_for_my_home_server