← sources

I over-designed my first game and I'm cutting it down to a simple decoration game. Will "simple" hurt me later ?

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-01 15:05ingested 2026-11-02 02:38

retained text

Hi everyone. I'm a solo developer with a 3D art background, working on my first commercial game, a cozy decoration game on Steam. I'm not linking it because I'm here for advice, not wishlists.

I'm currently doing mandatory military service, probably until early 2027. I can work in the evenings after 5 PM, which comes to roughly 12 to 15 hours a week. Over the past months I kept adding systems: currency, a shop, refunds, keepsakes, pets, plants. Every "innovative" idea cost me weeks. So I cut almost everything. The new version is level based: the room is ready, a box arrives, you unpack and place the items, and the level ends. No rewards, no penalties, just the calm part I actually enjoyed building. My goal is a demo with a main menu and 3 levels by the end of December, a Next Fest in June 2027 and an actual finished release.

The first thing I'm stuck on is my Steam page. It no longer matches the game; the description still explains the old loop, and my first dev update promised pets and plants. I have about 160 wishlists. How should I rewrite the page and tell those people the game has changed without it looking like I gave up? Would a short "what changed and why" update be enough ?

My second worry is simplicity itself. I'm afraid of releasing "just another decoration game," but every time I tried to add a unique twist, it set me back. For a first game, is a small, polished, finished game better than an ambitious one that never ships Or does a game without a strong hook just disappear on Steam?

The third is my long-term career. Later on Id like to do a master's degree in a game-related field and maybe go into academia. Could shipping a simple game hurt that ? Do admissions committees or academic hiring care how innovative your shipped game is, or more that you finished it and can explain what you learned ?

Finally, for anyone who made a game during military service, a full-time job, or something similar: what kept you going without burning out ?

Thanks for reading

document fetched 2026-11-02 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xl5bcl/i_overdesigned_my_first_game_and_im_cutting_it