The "spirit" of open-source?
retained text
This subreddit's description currently states: > A subreddit for everything open source related (for this context, we go off the definition of open source here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open\_source) I'm hoping this inquiry/discussion is in-line with that, even given the recent planned updates in the currently [pinned post](https://www.reddit.com/r/opensource/s/AQWpcVvcS0) and the barrage of backlash currently happening, which may be affecting the judgments for post removals. I'm around 5 YOE professionally in the SWE space, but have only meaningfully contributed to a handful of open-source projects (some with hundreds of active end-users) over the years, so I'm genuinely unfamiliar on what people more involved in the open-source community space (here in this subreddit and also more broadly) actually value in something being "open source" and the general culture/spirit behind the community. To me, as a bit of a newbie, "open source" simply brings to mind sharing, transparency, collaboration, and freedom of use/modification. I was admittedly unfamiliar with formal OSI licenses until reading through the mod post, but I thought the "absolute non-discrimination" aspect of it was an interesting pillar establishing freedom of use and creative expression without gaurd-rails against the "good" or "bad" derivative works that branch off from it. So my impression then is that this subreddit is meant to be a broad umbrella entry-point "for everything open source related," but some of the points outlined in the recent modpost after a few passes seems to be at odds with that. I do fully understand moderating out the 10,000x "I used AI to build a todo app" and wanting to curate high-effort discussions, but the upcoming restrictions seem incredibly gate-keepy to establishing what is classified as "the right type of open source project/contributors". Also with regards to [this comment](https://www.reddit.com/r/opensource/comments/1xelcuf/comment/19rlq7yzmz0o1/), pointing out some aspects seem to be poking at orthogonal directions to something being in the bucket of "everything open source related" So, with all of this in mind, I was just genuinely curious to hear from others more involved in the open source space (in and out of this subreddit) if my read on the culture/spirit of open source is correct or if I'm muddling some of the points of it. Thanks in advance \^\^ *(and thanks for reading through my wall of text)*
document fetched 2026-10-26 00:34 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/opensource/comments/1xfcbfp/the_spirit_of_opensource