← sources

First time doing cold email for a one person business. What reply rate told you it was worth continuing?

source: reddit (reddit:smallbusiness)published 2026-10-26 14:36ingested 2026-10-27 02:37

retained text

I run a small online business by myself and started cold email for the first time this month. I've sent about 60 short, plain text emails to businesses that actually fit what I do, and so far I've had one real reply.



What I can't figure out is how to judge it this early. What numbers would make you keep going, tweak it, or drop the channel completely?



For those who've done this:

\- What reply rate did you see at the start, and how many of those replies were actually interested?

\- How long did you give it before deciding?

\- Did most replies come from the first email or the follow ups?



Not selling anything here, just trying to set a realistic bar so I don't quit too early or keep going on something that isn't working.

document fetched 2026-10-27 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1xfykyi/first_time_doing_cold_email_for_a_one_person