← sources

Avoiding The "AI Slop" Epithet, Where Images Look Plasticky or Hollysloppy

source: reddit (reddit:comfyui)published 2026-10-27 12:49ingested 2026-10-28 02:38

retained text

This is a bit more of a philosophical post, but I have not seen it addressed yet by others (not to say nobody has addressed it), but in these past months I have noticed that the more, and more consistently, I push on generating higher bit rate AI images and video (being more consistent throughout the workflow) the more the resulting output seems like "real life" rather than Hollyslop.

By "Hollyslop", everyone knows the look, it is in nearly every movie with CGI, it is in any product coming out of Hollywood that is not an adult talky movie. The lighting, the sets, the post production, makes it seem apart from reality.

There was a time this was valued, as representing something 'bigger than life', the movie star with his or her perfect lighting, but it is also the sort of limited dynamic range that CGI often presents, one of the VERY few exceptions I can think of is the movie "Sunshine", where the CGI is visceral and is trying to imitate real life.

My point is, I have begun to forcefully press into NOT generating images and video in SDR then converting to HDR as a final step, but in trying to incorporate HDR gamut from the beginning, and the more I have done this, throughout my preproduction and into production, the more the final result looks like a REAL SCENE, rather than a cartoonish representation of it.

It is the same spaces, the same details, the same lighting, as an SDR scene, but that extra dynamic range, the extra NITS, make it resemble a photograph, and the unconscious eye reads it as that, as something 'real', even though it is obviously as fake as the SDR image placed next to it.  After all, real life has no clamps on it.

Seems if we want to take AI video to the next level, we need to press for more professional HDR tools and output, and play in that space, rather than treating HDR as a final throwaway step.

Just my two cents (about worth that too, heh).  I write this as a novice to the game, so I am guessing it has been discussed many times in certain professional circles I have not been privy to.

Thoughts?  Anyone else get the same impression?  I'd be curious to have a conversation around this.

document fetched 2026-10-28 00:41 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/comfyui/comments/1xgrmad/avoiding_the_ai_slop_epithet_where_images_look