← sources

How much a bad review affects the shop?

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-30 08:18ingested 2026-10-01 02:39

retained text

I'm a crochet pattern seller on Etsy, and I've maintained a 5-star rating for the past year. But over the past two weeks, two buyers have given me 1-star reviews.

One of them was angry with me because she left a negative review. I reached out to her and solved her problem, but I asked her to amend her review if she felt that her problem had been resolved. But my messages were AI-assisted because English is not my first language. She updated her already bad review to rage-bait me and wrote, "This seller is totally AI. Don't trust her."

Then another 1-star review came this week. She didn't tell me what her problem was or message me at all. She went straight to leaving a 1-star review.

My rating has now dropped to 4.7, but I want to ask: when future buyers visit my shop, will they see these reviews and think that I'm selling AI-generated patterns? I have responded publicly to both reviews and explained that my work is original, but I'm still worried.

I have 33 5-star reviews and 2 1-star reviews.

document fetched 2026-10-01 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wtzcwz/how_much_a_bad_review_affects_the_shop