Even the people building AI keep proposing currencies for the post-singularity world
retained text
Every post-scarcity proposal I’ve seen still has money baked into it, and a lot of these ideas come from the people building AI in the first place. **Sam Altman’s “Moore’s Law for Everything”** proposed an American Equity Fund that would pay citizens in dollars and shares of companies. That’s cash and assets. **Altman again:** He’s suggested that compute could become a currency of the future and floated the idea of universal basic compute. Same concept, different unit. **Elon Musk’s “universal high income”** is still income. It’s money with a bigger number. **Worldcoin** is a token designed to distribute a share of an AI-driven economy. **Andrew Yang’s Freedom Dividend** and the UBI studies Altman helped fund through OpenResearch are both based on cash payments. Even people who think money could eventually become irrelevant keep proposing systems that look a lot like money. Musk has talked about money becoming irrelevant while also proposing universal high income. It seems like money will stick around in some form, especially since people aren’t going to take kindly to a new system that ignores all the wealth they’ve already accumulated. The problem is that making intelligence cheap doesn’t eliminate scarcity. AGI could make cognitive labor nearly free, but it can’t make everything else infinite. \- **Land**, especially in city centers and desirable coastal areas. \- **Fresh water**, particularly in regions where access is limited and desalination requires energy and infrastructure. \- **Energy and compute**, which could become major bottlenecks in an AI-driven economy. \- **Raw materials** that still need to be extracted, processed, and transported. \- **Status and attention**. Fred Hirsch wrote about positional goods, and Nick Bostrom’s *Deep Utopia* explores what a world beyond traditional work might look like. There will also only ever be one original Mona Lisa. Whenever something is limited and multiple people want it, some system has to determine who gets it. Prices are useful because they communicate information about supply and demand. Replacing dollars with credits, tokens, or contribution points just changes the name of a system we already have. Does anyone think there’s a realistic system where money eventually disappears? I feel like it’ll still exist in some form, even if AI makes most things incredibly cheap. The real question is what UBI would actually cover and what counts as enough to live comfortably. Food, housing, utilities, and healthcare? Or enough to afford a decent lifestyle? There will always be scarce things like prime real estate, and I doubt people will accept a new system that disregards the wealth they’ve already built up. Politicians, billionaires, and other people in positions of power have plenty of assets to protect, so I imagine any transition would be designed to preserve existing wealth to some extent. At that point, are we really moving beyond money, or just changing how it works?
document fetched 2026-10-13 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/1x3pxhi/even_the_people_building_ai_keep_proposing