Should AI writing disclosure be about degree of use rather than a yes/no question?
retained text
There’s an interesting argument in this Fortune piece that the question “Did you use AI?” is becoming too simplistic for writing. There’s obviously a big difference between using AI to brainstorm or fact-check, asking it to polish something you already wrote, having it rewrite sections, and giving it a prompt to generate the entire article. Treating all of those as simply “AI-written” makes the disclosure pretty meaningless. The author proposes a self-reported scale ranging from completely human-written to AI-generated with minimal editing. I actually think this is a more useful way to think about AI-assisted writing because the important question isn't necessarily whether AI was involved, but **how much of the actual writing came from it**. Would a standardized disclosure like this make AI use in writing more transparent, or would it just create another labeling system that people ignore? [Fortune: Stop asking writers if they used AI. Just ask them how much](https://fortune.com/2026/09/29/ai-writing-witch-hunt-new-spectrum-ghostwriting/)
document fetched 2026-09-30 00:20 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1wtgz80/should_ai_writing_disclosure_be_about_degree_of