← sources

My value filter says Alphabet is worth $72 a share. Is $160B a year of AI capex a cost or an investment?

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-11-03 13:14ingested 2026-11-04 02:42

retained text

Before I read a 10-K, a company has to pass a first filter: five numbers from classic value investing books. Alphabet just failed it, and I'm not sure I trust the result, so I'd like your take.

GOOGL, price $279.75 (Nov 3), financials through the September quarter:

1. **Earnings yield: 6.8%** 🟢 About $6.80 of yearly profit per $100 you pay (industry median 5.5%). But net income ($236B over 12 months) is far above operating income ($157B), mostly gains on its investment stakes. On operating profit after tax it's closer to 4%, which would be red.
2. **Return on capital: 28%** 🟢 $157B of operating profit on $559B of working capital + fixed assets. Above my 15% line and the industry median (26%).
3. **Acquirer's Multiple: 20.3x** 🔴 Enterprise value $3.19T (already net of $56B cash and $344B of investments) / operating earnings. Meta is at 19.7x. The industry median is 12.7x, but that group is mostly small names like Yelp and NerdWallet, so not a great yardstick.
4. **FS-Score: 6/10** 🟡 Gray & Carlisle's 10-point version of the Piotroski F-Score. Profitability 3/3, stability 2/3 (debt went up), operating improvements 1/4 (return on assets flat, FCF/assets and asset turnover down; only gross margin improved).
5. **DCF: fair value $72, −74% vs the price** 🔴 It starts from trailing free cash flow of $19.7B, down from $73.3B in 2025, because capex was $160B over the last 12 months. 14% FCF growth for 10 years, 9% discount rate, 3% terminal growth. Revenue grew 15.1% last year and 17.2%/yr over 5 years.

**Result: 2 greens, 1 yellow, 2 reds. It doesn't pass.**

The DCF is the problem. It starts from free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capex), and capex has exploded:

• 2025: $165B operating cash flow − $91B capex = $73B free cash flow → fair value $223
• Last 12 months: $180B − $160B = $20B → fair value $72
• If most capex is growth spending that stops: ~$180B − ~$30B = ~$150B → fair value ~$450

Two questions:

1. **Is the capex an investment or the new maintenance cost?** They guide $195–205B for 2026 and more in 2027. How would you treat it in a valuation?
2. **At $280: buy, watchlist or pass?**

Disclosure: I  don't own GOOGL. to me there's too much uncertainty i wouldn't feel safe. The numbers come from a small free tool I built.

document fetched 2026-11-04 00:43 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xmsmbu/my_value_filter_says_alphabet_is_worth_72_a_share