← sources

Customer who first cancelled monthly subscription and then purchased annual subscription

source: reddit (reddit:SaaS)published 2026-10-22 16:13ingested 2026-10-23 02:39

retained text

After posting about getting first monthly subscription here at Reddit, I got few more subscriptions in next few weeks and then I got one customer who purchased monthly subscription but cancelled after few hours. When I asked him the reason, he said product was not what he expected. He thought product would allow him to write prompt and application will generate whole novel. Basically, he was asking for one-shot novel writing application (e.g. prompt to novel) but my application did not contain that feature and still don't. Here is why.

About my SaaS, NovelCanon is a writer-first and writer-friendly AI novel-writing studio built around a three-tier Consistency Engine which extracts the facts of every scene, tracks them across the whole manuscript, and flags contradictions. In addition, it consists of self-maintained Story Bible, AI Chat, scene editor consisting of rich set of writing features relevant to novel writing along with AI features including Continue Writing, Dialogue Writing, Brainstorming, Prose Enhancing etc. And, NovelCanon is based on Bring-Your-Own-Key (BYOK) so it naturally supports top AI providers like OpenAI, Claude, Gemini, and OpenRouter.

I could add new page in my application containing functionality that offers one-shot novel writing capability but that would have made my application lose focus and become jack of all and master of none.

When I started building NovelCanon, one of core objectives I set: Writer should be final authority and one-shot novel writing feature was totally against that core objective. Secondly, my target audience that I wanted to serve were writers or people who want to become novel writers and those who want to get involved in writing process no matter if they write whole novel or not even a single word. NovelCanon is built around the way that writers have to go through scene by scene and chapter by chapter and they have choice whether they write whole novel without AI features or they use AI to write each scene in each chapter.

Hence, I did not add any such features which were going against my core objectives, just to grab few subscriptions. It is well-known that one who try to serve everyone end up serving no one.

It is necessary for me to clarify that I totally respect people who want one-shot novel writing applications and encourage ones who want to serve them by building prompt-to-novel writing apps. I believe in "Give Space and Get Space" so everyone has right to choose applications that serve them well and everyone has right to choose their target audience that they want to serve.

When building things, we should be clear in our mind for whom we are building, who we want to serve, and what our product would do. If someone wants to learn about this cycle, should read about Apple company’s bad years from late 80s till mid 90s when Steve Jobs left and company lost focus and tried to serve everyone and became almost bankrupt and then Steve Jobs came back and made drastic changes, saved company from bankruptcy and set the stage which brought company where it is today.

So, I kept improving my product even though I lost one of my initial customers and few days later, one customer purchased monthly subscription and then cancelled it few hours later. I got little bit upset but then moved on saying this is part of game, some will stay and some won’t. But, surprisingly that same customer purchased annual subscription next day which encouraged what I believed in. I realized that he might cancelled it first because he wanted to first check things up and when he was done, he really liked NovelCanon that he went on to purchase annual subscription.

Would love to know the approach you take when building things and how you handle the situation when users leave your platform.

document fetched 2026-10-23 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xcmx21/customer_who_first_cancelled_monthly_subscription