Brazilian stock market probably overreacted to election results
retained text
This month in international markets saw significant volatility in Brazilian equities. EWZ, which tracks the MSCI Brazil GRTR USD index, surged +12.5% at the beginning of the month, as it priced in the probability of a Flavio Bolsonaro win after a strong showing in round one of the Brazilian elections. However, when the dust had settled, Lula unexpectedly came from behind, and the EWZ gave back all its gains and then some, with a -18.4% drop on Monday. I wanted to figure out the investors viewed Bolsonaro as so much more market friendly. Curiously, I found that the Brazilian stock market did extremely well during Lula's two prior terms and the third current term and was slightly negative during the presidency of Jair Bolsonaro, the father of losing candidate Flavio Bolsonaro. In Brazil, the presidential terms are four years long and align neatly with the calendar year. This makes it really easy to track returns using the [MSCI Brazil](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/907600), which would be the gold standard anyway. All returns are gross returns using USD currency: |Term|Start|End|Total Return|CAGR| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |Lula 1|2003|2006|\+571.85%|\+61.10%| |Lula 2|2007|2010|\+93.14%|\+17.86%| |Bolsonaro|2019|2022|(-2.47%)|(-0.62%)| |Lula 3|2023|10/27/26|\+56.63%|\+12.45%| |Lula, Total|\--|\--|\+1932.44%|\+29.01%| I certainly would not have expected the less market friendly candidate to outperform his counterpart (presumably with similar policies as his son) by such a drastic margin, even after eating that monster -18.4% single day drop this week. However, to be fair, Lula 1 was an incredible time for emerging markets, one which likely could not be reproduced again. And Bolsonaro's presidency coincided with the pandemic, which could have hampered returns. To control for this, I compared the MSCI Brazil against several other benchmarks to which the country belongs. ACWI includes all countries, ACWI ex-USA is the international market excluding the USA, and emerging markets are the MSCI emerging markets. Additionally, while Brazil does not belong to the MSCI USA, MSCI World (a misnomer which means developed markets including USA), and MSCI World ex-USA (developed markets excluding USA), these are included for comparison. Brazil has trounced all of these benchmarks under Lula's presidency and badly lagged all of them under Jair Bolsonaro. |Index|Lula, Total|Lula, CAGR|Bolsonaro, Total|Bolsonaro, CAGR| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |[MSCI Brazil](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/907600)|\+1932.44%|\+29.01%|(-2.47%)|(-0.62%)| |[MSCI ACWI](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/892400)|\+324.38%|\+13.00%|\+45.23%|\+9.78%| |[MSCI ACWI ex-USA](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/899901)|\+375.95%|\+14.10%|\+24.09%|\+5.55%| |[MSCI Emerging Markets](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/106062)|\+618.13%|\+18.14%|\+15.49%|\+3.67%| |[MSCI USA](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/984000)|\+262.78%|\+11.51%|\+63.39%|\+13.07%| |[MSCI World](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/990100)|\+299.54%|\+12.43%|\+50.56%|\+10.78%| |[MSCI World ex-USA](https://www.msci.com/indexes/index/991000)|\+321.97%|\+12.95%|\+29.83%|\+6.75%|
document fetched 2026-10-29 00:33 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/1xhgo9m/brazilian_stock_market_probably_overreacted_to